Full Order Text
Order 17 · 09 Jun 2026 · CNR DLCT010099812024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS (COMM) 731/24 Puran Chand And Co Vs. Smt Babita Gupta 09.06.2026 Present : Mr. Rajesh Mahendru, Ld. counsel for the plaintiff. Mr. Prabhat Ranjan, Ld. counsel for defendant. An application under Sec. 151 CPC moved by the defendant seeking condonation of delay in paying the monthly rent stands allowed in the interest of justice. The cheque in the sum of Rs.33,267/- as arrears of the rent for the last six months is handed over to the Ld. counsel for the plaintiff. Receiving of the same taken on previous ordersheet. Further, arguments heard on the application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC moved on behalf of the defendant. The amendments which are sought to be incorporated by the defendant are in the form of preliminary objections to say that “the tenanted premises are not legally permissible for commercial use and unauthorized commercial use in residential property does not make it a commercial dispute unless such use is permitted by the and reflected in the MCD/ NDMC records”. The amendments are strongly objected by the Ld. counsel for the plaintiff on the grounds that the defendants have specifically admitted the commercial use of the premises in question in terms of their earlier written statements filed before the competent Authority Slum Areas Delhi, and vide this amendment they are seeking to withdraw their earlier admission to its commercial use. In response to the submissions of the Ld. counsel for the plaintiff, defendant has highlighted an order dated 13.01.2025 vide which an application moved under Order 7 rule 10 r/w 151 CPC seeking rejection of the plaint was dismissed by the Predecessor of the Contd…. -- 1 of 2 -- - : 2 :- Court with the observation that the factum of the issue whether the tenancy was commercial or not and whether it was for residential cum commercial purpose can not be decided in a summary manner…. and if required, the Court shall frame issues at an appropriate stage in this regard. Taking note of the submissions of the counsel(s), and the observations made by the Predecessor Court in terms of the order dated 13.01.2015 and also the fact that preliminary objections sought to be incorporated are legal objections which the Court is, in any case is bound to consider all the legal aspects, the objections including the maintainability of the Suit in terms thereof at the time of deciding the case, in the interest of the justice, the application seeking amendment of the WS stands allowed without prejudice to the rights and contentions of the plaintiff and the specific admissions so made by the defendant in their pleadings subject to cost of Rs.5,000/-, out of which Rs.3,000/- be given to the plaintiff and Rs.2,000/- be deposited with the Delhi Legal Services Authority. Application stands disposed off. The amended WS stands taken on record. Replication, if any be filed on within two weeks from today with advance copy to the opposite side. Parties are also directed to file affidavit of admission the last opportunity. Renotify for case management hearing / framing of issues on 16.07.2026. (Anil Antil) District Judge, Commercial Court-09, Central, THC, Delhi 09.06.2026 -- 2 of 2 --
