Full Order Text
Order 14 · 16 Jan 2026 · CNR DLCT010099812024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: CS (COMM) 731/24 Puran Chand And Co Vs. Smt Babita Gupta 16.01.2026 Present: Sh. Rajesh Mahendru, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff along with partner of the plaintiff firm in person. Sh. Prabhat Ranjan, Ld. Counsel for the defendant along with defendant no. 3 in person. On the last date of hearing it was stated by ld. Counsel for the defendants that parties are exploring the possibility of settlement and the matter is likely to be settled in terms of the understanding between them. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff had stated that he was not aware about this development. In view of the same, both the parties were directed to appear today. Today, Sh. Narender Kumar, partner of the plaintiff firm and Sh. Akshay Gupta, defendant no. 3 have appeared in court. It is stated by defendant no. 3 that on 06.12.2025, Sh. Narender Kumar along with his son Sarthak had come to the shop of Sh. Jagmohan Aggarwal at Sanghi Saree, Chandni Chowk, Delhi where Sh. Rakesh the property dealer was also present and in their presence, both the parties i.e. Sh. Narender Kumar and he himself had agreed for the settlement of the case and Sh. Narender Kumar agreed to sell the property in question for consideration which was agreeable to him. In compliance of the same, at that moment itself, he handed over a cheque in a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs to Sh. Narender Kumar and his son Sh. Sarthak, who accepted the same but contd..2 -- 1 of 3 -- -2- returned the same to him around 10-15 days later and further they also demanded the entire arrear of the rental amount at that moment itself but he stated that he will pay the same in the court. They also handed over to him four pages of the previous registry and asked him to get the papers ready for the sale deed. On the other hand, it is stated by Sh. Narender Kumar, partner of the plaintiff that around 4/5 months back the defendant had given the offer to buy the property in question but he did not agree as he wanted the property to be vacated by the defendants and hence, the talks for the settlement did not materialize. He further stated that he knows Sh. Jagmohan Aggarwal c/o Sanghi Saree and Sh. Rakesh who is a property dealer there, but he never conveyed through them his offer to the defendant to sell the property to him and that on 6.12.2025 he never went to the shop of Sh. Jagmohan Aggarwal at Sanghi Saree, Chandni Chowk, Delhi. In view of the same, in my view, it is required that the statement of both the parties on oath be recorded in the court. Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has objected to the recording of statement of plaintiff stating that it will only delay the proceedings and in totality it is not required as it is not expedient to record the statement in such situation. During the court proceedings it is expected that both the parties must come out clean and there should not be any concealment on their part. Contd...3 -- 2 of 3 -- -3- In my view, the objections raised by Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff has no merit. There is direct and material contradiction between the parties regarding the alleged talks for sale having taken place between the parties outside the court and at least one of the parties is not coming out clean and rather telling lie in the open court and making mockery of the Court proceedings. The court is not helpless in such situation. In order to ascertain the truthfulness and bonafide of the respective stands of the parties and for proper adjudication of the matter, in my view, the court deems it appropriate to examine both the parties under Order 10 read with Section 151 CPC regarding the stand taken by them at the alleged meeting on 06.12.2025 as it also reflects the credibility of both the parties. Accordingly, statement of Sh. Narender Kumar, partner of plaintiff firm and Sh. Akshay Gupta, defendant no. 3 has been recorded on oath in the court in that regard. Accordingly, issue notice to Sh. Jagmohan Aggarwal of Sanghi Saree and Sh. Rakesh, Property Dealer to appear in person in court on NDOH. Their addresses and complete particulars be furnished by the defendant to the Court. Accordingly, put up for examination as well as for consideration of the application of the defendant under Order VI Rule 17 CPC on 29.01.2026. (Deepak Garg) Distt. Judge, (Comm. Court)-09, Central District, THC : Delhi :16.01.2026 r -- 3 of 3 --
