Full Order Text
Final Order 5 · 15 Feb 2025 · CNR DLCT010086472024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.1 of 16 IN THE COURT OF MS. SHILPI JAIN, ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-02, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CNR No.DLCT01-008647-2024 Criminal Revision No. 240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr. IN THE MATTER OF : Shri Anil Kumar S/o Shri Sumer Singh R/o 8095-8097, Khariya Mohlla, Roshanara Road, Delhi ….Revisionist/Petitioner VERSUS 1. The State (NCT of Delhi) ….Respondent No.1 2. Laxman Kohli S/o Late Shri Maruti Lal Kohli R/o 669, Mukimpura, Gali Mandir Wali, Purani Subzi Mandi, Delhi ….Respondent No.2 DATE OF INSTITUTION : 04.07.2024 ORDER RESERVED ON : 15.02.2025 DATE OF ORDER : 15.02.2025 O R D E R 1. Vide this order, this Court shall decide revision petition under Section 397 read with Section 399 Cr.PC moved on behalf of revisionist against the impugned order dated 09.02.2024 passed by Sh. Arjun Kirar, Ld. MM-04, Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi in Misc Crl. No. 245/2022 case titled as -- 1 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.2 of 16 Anil Kumar Vs. Laxman Kohli whereby it was ordered that the application under Section 340 Cr.PC will be decided after the main complaint is decided. 2. It is averred that one complaint was filed under Section 138 NI Act against the revisionist by respondent no.2 on 09.07.2018 and same was registered as CC no.13491/2018. It is further averred that on 28.08.2019 , notice under Section 251 Cr.PC was framed against the accused and plea of defence of revisionist has been recorded. It is further averred that statement of accused/revisionist was recorded under Section 294 Cr.PC and as per order the cheque and legal notice was admitted by the revisionist and accordingly witness at serial no.2 in the list of witnesses was dropped and opportunity for cross- examination of complainant/respondent no.2 was granted to the revisionist for 26.11.2019. It is further averred that complainant has been partly cross-examined in the aforesaid case. BRIEF FACTS OF THE COMPLAINT 3. The brief facts of the case is that as per the complaint an agreement for the construction was executed and signed by the both the revisionist/accused and respondent No.2 on dated 03.09.2016 for the total sum of Rs. 18,00,000/-. As per the agreement, the revisionist was supposed to pay Rs. 3,00,000/- in advance to the respondent no.2 and the entire construction was to be completed within 6-7 months from the date of the execution of the agreement. 4. It is further submitted that as per the complaint, revisionist could not pay the advance payment of Rs. 3,00,000/- to the respondent no.2 and requested to the respondent no.2 that he will pay the amount later on, please start the demolition of the said property. -- 2 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.3 of 16 5. It is further submitted that in the meantime, on 08.11.2016, Govt. of India, implemented the demonetization of money scheme as such the accused/revisionist shown his inability to make the payment and the respondent no.2 started to work by taking the building material on credit basis from the suppliers. 6. It is further submitted that on 19.11.2016, the Lintel of the ground floor of the said property was laid down but no money paid by the revisionist to the respondent no.2 and on dated 09.12.2016, the lintel of the first floor of the said property was laid down but no money paid by the revisionist to the respondent no.2 and on dated 25.12.2016, the lintel of the second floor of the said property was laid down but no money paid by the revisionist to the respondent no.2 and on dated 10.01.2017, the lintel of the third floor of the said property was laid down but no money paid by the revisionist to the respondent no.2. 7. It is further submitted that at lastly in the month of May 2017, the respondent no.2 completed in the construction work, as per the terms and conditions of the agreement dated 03.09.2016 except the affixing of the main door and a door on the roof. 8. It is further submitted that after the completion of the work, the revisionist was not in position to pay the amount of Rs. 18,00,000/- as per the agreement as such a new agreement was executed between the parties and the physical possession of the second floor of the said property was handed over to the respondent no.2 in lieu of the amount/agreed amount of the construction. 9. It is further submitted that on dated 29.12.2017, the respondent no.2 visited the second floor and found the lock of the respondent no.2 -- 3 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.4 of 16 was removed and the accused/revisionist illegally occupying the possession of the second floor of the respondent no.2 and committing the offence of tresspassing. 10. It is further submitted that the revisionist moved an application dated 16.01.2018 to the various authorities on 17.01.2018. 11. It is further submitted that on dated 05.02.2018, accused/revisionist offered to compromise with respondent no.2 in the police station Subzi Mandi, Delhi, revisionist offer of Rs. 12 lacs out of Rs. 18,00,000/- plus interest by way of three post dated cheque bearing no. 668367 to 668369 of total amount of Rs.12 lacs (each of Rs.4,00,000/-) and the respondent no.2 accepted the offer and take the post dated cheque and the matter was compromised in the police station Subzi Mandi and in respect of the above said compromise, a writing was executed by the revisionist in presence of the police personal and his friend Bal Kishan. 12. It is further submitted that on dated 05.05.2018, cheque was presented for encashment but the same was dishonoured with remarks "Stopped by drawer" vide returning memo dated 08.05.2018 and the third cheque 20.05.2018 was returned dishonor with remarks payment "stopped by drawer" vide returning memo dated 23.05.2018. 13. It is further submitted that the legal notice was sent to the revisionist on 26.05.2018 by the respondent no.2 by the Speed post and courier, but after receiving of the legal demand notice, the revisionist did not pay the cheques amount. 14. It is further submitted that the respondent no.2 filed a case against the revisionist on dated 09.07.2018. -- 4 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.5 of 16 15. It is further submitted that the Ld. Trial Court framed the notice Us 251 Cr.P.c. on 28.08.2019, hence the revision petition. 16. It is further submitted that after the receipt of the summons and annexures i.e. cheques, agreement dated 03.09.2016 & 10.06.2016 and other various documents, it is revealed that the documents filed by the complainant Laxman Kohli in this present complaint case is false and fabricated because the documents i.e. agreements dated 03.09.2016 is different from agreement which was filed by the Laxman Kohli in FIR No. 42/2018 and the agreement dated 10.06.2017 is also different, the agreement filed with the IO in the FIR no.42/2018. As such an application u/s 340 Cr.P.C.was filed by the present revisionist against the Laxman Kohli which is registered as Misc. No. Crl.245/2022. 17. It is further submitted that a detailed reply on behalf of the respondent no.2 on 28.04.2023. 18. It is further submitted that on dated 09.02.2024 at the time of argument on the application 340 Cr.P.C., the Ld.Court passed the order that " the present application u/s 340 Cr.P.C. will be decided after the main complaint case is decided" and the application U/s 340 Cr.PC. attached with the main file, hence this revision petition. The impunged order dated 09.02.2024 passed by the Ld. MM, TIs Hazari Courts, Delhi, is liable to be set aside by this Hon'ble Court on following grounds: Grounds of Revision (a) It is averred that the impugned order is illegal and based upon surmises and conjectures and there is no merit in the impugned order passed by the Ld.MM. -- 5 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.6 of 16 (b) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the proposed accused has fabricated the documents i.e. agreements and on the basis of the these documents/agreements, the respondent no.2 lodged a false and fabricated FIR bearing no. 42/2018 and the case Us 138 NI Act against the present revisionist. (c) That the order passed by the Ld. MM is liable to the set-aside because the Ld. MM has failed to appreciate that the respondent no.2 himself filed the two different agreement dated 03.09.2016 before Ld. court and IO of the FIR No. 42/2018. (d) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the revisionist file the documents related to the building material supply to the respondent no.2 by the suppliers on page no. 19 to 21 of M/s Ankit Trading Co., in which the bills no. 32 & 33 are showing that the material of the cement of 100 Katte was purchased on dated 27.10.2016 vide bill no.32 and 100 katta of the cement was purchased on 03/11/2016 vide Bill no.33, as such it is proved that prior to the demonetization scheme, the respondent no.2 has already purchased most of the building construction material as such the construction has already started and the money of Rs.3,00,000/- has already taken by the respondent no.2 from the revisionist. It is pertinent to mention here that the articles of the cement was purchased on 27.10.2016 and same day the bill no.32 was executed by the Shopkeeper and 100 kattas of the cement was purchased on 03.11.2016 by the respondent no.2 from the Ankit Trading company and bill was executed on 03.11.2016 vide bill book no. 33. the bill no. 32 was dated 27.10.2016 and bill No.33 was dated -- 6 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.7 of 16 03.11.2016 was executed, it revealed that a lot of days have been passed between the two bills but the serial number of the bills are on serials 32 & 33. It is averred that said bills are false and fabricated by the respondent no.2. (e) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the respondent no.2 himself admitted in his reply that two identical copies of the agreement dated 03.09.2016 were got prepared and in cross examination, the respondent no.2 clearly admitted that only one agreement dated 03.09.2016 was prepared and executed and same has been signed only once by the parties. (f) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that as per the respondent no.2, he himself filed the reply dated 28.04.2023 to the application U/s 340 Cr.P.C. wherein the respondent no.2 admitted that two identical copies of the agreement dated 03.09.2016 were got prepared and one copy was duly signed by both the parties and got notarized on 03.09.2016 alongwith photographs of the complainant and the copy was kept by the respondent no.2 and other set of the documents was duly signed but was not got notarized and the copy was kept by the revisionist and in the cross examination, the respondent no.2 clearly admitted that only one agreement was prepared and same was signed and 2-3 photocopy was taken. (g) It is further averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the present application U/s 340 Cr.P.C. is based on the documentary evidence and the documents itself speaks about the fabrication of these documents. It is further averred that it is crystal clear from the -- 7 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.8 of 16 signatures that photographs of the revisionist was affixed on the one agreement when the agreement is filed by the respondent no.2 with the case U/s 138 NI Act. (h) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that another agreement dated 10.06.2017 was executed between the wife of the revisionist and the respondent no.2 but it is found that the agreement was executed by the revisionist and the photographs was on the agreement of revisionist, whenever the agreement was executed in the name of Smt. Kusum Lata Wife of the revisionist. It is further submitted that the said photographs of the revisionist was taken from the Facebook and signature of the revisionist was fabricated by the respondent no.2 as such no agreement was executed by the revisionist, the revisionist has already filed the complaint to the various authority and already filed a complaint u/s 156 (3) & 200 Cr.P.C. before the Ld. Trial Court. (i) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the respondent admitted in his complaint that an FIR no. 42/2018, U/s 420/448/506 of IPC, P.S. Subzi Mandi was lodged against the accused/revisionist but the respondent no.2 did not whisper about the date of registration of the FIR as 05.02.2018 and the compromise dated 05.02.2018, in which three post dated cheques were taken by the respondent no.2 from the revisionist in the presence of the police and surprisingly on the same day the FIR No. 42/2018, U/s 420/448/506 IPC lodged at P.S Suzbi Mandi against the revisionist. (j) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the -- 8 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.9 of 16 revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the property was in the name of Smt. Kusum Lata W/o Sh.Anil Kumar and the property which was demolished and constructed by the respondent no.2 is in the name of Kusum Lata and the agreement of the construction was showing the signature of the accused /revisionist, whenever no any legal liability was occurred against the present revisionist. (k) It is averred that the order passed by Ld.MM against the revisionist is totally ignoring the fact that the agreement dated 10.06.2017, for the delivery the peaceful and vacant possession to the respondent no.2 is totally false and fabricated by the respondent no.2 and the signature of the revisionist is false and fabricated by the respondent no.2 and the photo of the revisionist was taken from the Facebook. (l) It is averred that the revisionists have not filed any other similar petition either in the Hon'ble Supreme court or any High Court except the present one. (m) It is further averred that this Hon'ble Court has got jurisdiction to try and entertain the present petition. 19. It is prayed that order dated 09.02.2024 whereby the order was passed that the application under Section 340 Cr.PC will be decided after the main complaint decided be set aside and revision petition be allowed. 20. Ld. counsel for the revisionist has relied upon following judgment/citations:- (a) State of Punjab v. Jasbir Singh 2022; -- 9 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.10 of 16 (b) Ashok Gulabro Bondre v. Vilas Madhukarrao Deshmukh & Ors.; (c) Surjeet Singh & Ors v. Balbir Singh; (d) CBI v. M. Shivamani 2017; (e) Narendra Kumar Srivastava v. State of Bihar, 2019, 3 SCC 318; and (f) Amarsang Nathaji v. Hardik Patel 2017: 21. Respondent chose not to file reply but directly addressed arguments. Respondent vehemently opposed the present revision petition and submitted that it is filed merely to delay the proceedings. It is further submitted that impugned order was rightly passed by the Trial court after considering facts and circumstances of the case and material on record. It is further submitted that alleged forged agreement was recovered from the possession of revisionist only and one FIR pertaining to same transaction has already been registered wherein thorough investigation is going on by the investigating agency. 22. It is further submitted that application under Section 340 Cr.PC filed by the revisionist was not in the nature of expediency in the administration of justice, rather it defeats the said purpose. 23. It is submitted that it is the discretion of the Ld. Trial Court depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case whether application under Section 340 Cr.PC is to be decided first or it is to be decided after the trial of the main complaint case. It is -- 10 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.11 of 16 further submitted that Ld. Trial Court has rightly decided in the present matter that the application should be decided after the main complaint as it requires evidence to be led by the parties to the case and admittedly only part cross-examination of respondent no.2 has been done till in the main case. 24. It is further submitted that scope of interference in revision petition is narrow and limited only for the purpose of considering correctness, legality or propriety of any finding inter se an order and as to the regularity of the proceedings of any inferior court. It is further averred that the revisional court does not dwell at length upon the facts of the case. 25. It is further averred that revisionist failed to disclose at to what facts and circumstances have not been dealt by Ld. MM. It is submitted that impugned order was passed after considering all the material allegations and the fact that even the cross- examination of complainant/respondent no.2 is yet to be completed. 26. It is prayed that the revision petition filed by the revisionist be dismissed with cost. 27. I have heard the arguments and perused the record and relied upon citations carefully. 28. Revisionist has filed the present revision petition against impugned order dated 09.02.2024 passed by Ld. Trial court, whereby the application of revisionist under Section 340 Cr.PC is kept pending for deciding the same after the decision of main -- 11 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.12 of 16 complaint case. 29. It is submitted by ld. Counsel for the revisionist that Ld. Trial Court failed to appreciate facts and circumstances of the case in hand and passed the non-speaking impugned order without dealing with facts and evidence which are on record. 30. Before proceedings further, it is necessary to go through the impugned order dated 09.02.2024 passed by Ld. Trial court which is reproduced as under:- “Misc Crl. 245/2022 Anil Kumar Vs. Laxman Kohli 09.02.2024 Present : Sh. Santosh, Ld. Counsel for the Complainant. Ms. Anu Verma, Ld. Counsel for the accused. Accused in person. Perusal of record reveals that the reply to the application u/s 340 Cr.PC is already on record. The application will be decided after the main complaint case is decided. Be attached with the main file on 16.05.2024. -sd- (Arjun Kirar) MM-04, NI Act, Central District, THC 09.02.2024” 31. Perusal of TCR and impugned order reveals that revisionist has taken all the aforesaid pleas, which are taken in the present revision petition before the Ld. Trial Court in his -- 12 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.13 of 16 application and reply to the application has also been filed by the respondent and the same has been duly considered by the said Court as reflected in the impugned order dated 09.02.2024. It is pertinent to note that trial court mentioned in the said order that reply to the application is already on record and application will be decided after the main complaint case is decided. It gives an inference that Ld. Trial Court is of the view that the facts of case are such that the veracity of the contentions/claims can only be determined upon conclusion of trial. This court is also of the view that it is only upon completion of trial proceedings that the truthfulness of the allegation can be ascertained with certainity especially keeping in mind that one FIR apart from main complaint case under Section 138 NI Act has also been registered pertaining to transaction in question wherein thorough investigation is going on by the police officials. 32. Coming now to the case law, while discussing the power of the revisionist court, Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Munna Devi v. State of Rajasthan and Ors., AIR 2002 SC 107, it has been held by the Supreme Court as under: “3. ...The revision power under the Code of Criminal Procedure cannot be exercised in a routine and casual manner. While exercising such powers the High Court has no authority to appreciate the evidence in the manner as the trial and the appellate courts are required to do. Revisional powers could be exercised only when it is shown that there is a legal bar against the continuance of the criminal proceedings or the framing of charge or the facts as stated in the First Information Report even if they are taken at the face value and accepted in their entirety do not constitute -- 13 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.14 of 16 the offence for which the accused has been charged. This Court in Kanti Bhadra Sha & Anr. v. State of West Bengal, 2000 CriLJ 746 has held that there is no legal requirement for the trial court to write a reasoned or lengthy order for framing the charges.” 33. Also, the present court have to keep in mind that revisional jurisdiction is normally to be exercised in exceptional cases where there is a glaring defect in procedure or there is manifest error of law and consequently there has been a flagrant miscarriage of justice. In Taron Mohan v. State & Anr, 2021 SCC OnLine Del 312, Hon'ble Delhi High Court has observed as under:- “ 9. The scope of interference in a revision petition is extremely narrow. It is well settled that Section 397 CrPC gives the High Courts or the Sessions Courts jurisdiction to consider the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding inter se an order and as to the regularity of the proceedings of any inferior court. It is also well settled that while considering the legality, propriety or correctness of a finding or a conclusion, normally the revising court does not dwell at length upon the facts and evidence of the case. A court in revision considers the material only to satisfy itself about the legality and propriety of the findings, sentence and order and refrains from substituting its own conclusion on an elaborate consideration of evidence." 34. Further, Hon'ble Apex Court in Sanjay Singh Ramrao Chavan v. Dattatray Gulabrao Phalke and others, 2015 (3) SCC 123 wherein it has been observed as under : “ 14.....Unless the order passed by the Magistrate is perverse or the view taken by the court is wholly -- 14 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.15 of 16 unreasonable or there is non-consideration of any relevant material or there is palpable misreading of records, the Revisional Court is not justified in setting aside the order, merely because another view is possible. The Revisional Court is not meant to act as an appellate court. The whole purpose of the revisional jurisdiction is to preserve the power in the court to do justice in accordance with the principles of criminal jurisprudence. The revisional power of the court under Sections 397 to 401 CrPC is not to be equated with that of an appeal. Unless the finding of the court, whose decision is sought to be revised, is shown to be perverse or untenable in law or is grossly erroneous or glaringly unreasonable or where the decision is based on no material or where the material facts are wholly ignored or where the judicial discretion is exercised arbitrarily or capriciously, the courts may not interfere with decision in exercise of their revisional jurisdiction." 35. Applying the aforesaid principle of law to the facts and circumstances of the case as well as law as discussed in preceding paragraphs, it is crystal clear that Ld. Trial Court has rightly passed the order dated 09.02.2024 as per law. Accordingly, no material brought on record to challenge correctness, legality and propriety of the impugned order dated 09.02.2024 which is sine qua non for invoking revisional jurisdiction. It cannot be said at this stage that conclusion arrived by the Ld. Trial Court is unreasonable and unjustified, calling for interference by the present Court in exercise of revisional jurisdiction. I do not find any infirmity or flaw in the impugned order passed by Ld. Trial Court. Accordingly, the revision petition is dismissed. -- 15 of 16 -- CR No.240/2024 Anil Kumar Vs. State & Anr.. Page No.16 of 16 36. Accordingly, Revision Petition is disposed off as dismissed. 37. Nothing said herein shall tantamount to have effect on the merits of the case. Trial Court record be sent back alongwith the copy of this order. 38. Revision file be consigned to Record Room after due compliance. Copy of order be given dasti to the revisionist. Announced in the Open Court (Shilpi Jain) on 15th day of February, 2025 Additional Sessions Judge-02, Central District, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi -- 16 of 16 --
