Full Order Text
Final Order 3 · 26 Jul 2023 · CNR DLCT010086032023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SHRI NAROTTAM KAUSHAL PRINCIPAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS JUDGE (CENTRAL) TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI. RCT no. 32/2023 CNR No. DLCT010086032023 Shri Dharmender Tomar S/o Sh. Rattan Lal, R/o House No. 2989, Masjid Khajoor, Kinari Bazar, Delhi110006 …...APPELLANT VERSUS Smt. Kamla Devi, W/o late Sh. Balbir Singh, R/o House No. 1445, Bazar Gulian, Dariba Kalan, Delhi110006 ......RESPONDENT Date of filing : 03.07.2023 First date before this court : 03.07.2023 Arguments concluded on :26.07.2023 Date of Decision : 26.07.2023 APPEARANCE : Sh. Ajay Gupta, counsel for appellant Sh. Veer Chand, counsel for respondent O R D E R : 1. Present appeal is directed against order dated 31.05.2023 passed by the learned ACJcumAdditional Rent Controller, Central, RCT no. 32/2023 Dharmender Tomar Vs. Kamla Devi Page 1 of 4 pages -- 1 of 4 -- Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi in Eviction Petition bearing no. 853/2018 titled as 'Kamla Devi Vs. Dharmender Tomar'. 2. Sh. Gupta has referred to chronology of dates of hearing contained in para 8 (G) of the appeal. It is submitted that affidavit of the respondent herein i.e. petitioner before the trial court was tendered on 28.02.2023 and on account of large number of documents tendered, the examination-in-chief lasted for about one and half hour. The cross-examination was deferred on the said date for the next date i.e. 31.05.2023. Sh. Gupta himself, appearing for the present petitioners/respondents-tenants, could not appear before the trial court on account of his ill health. Therefore, an adjournment was sought for concluding the cross-examination. However, the trial court did not accommodate the counsel and closed the opportunity for cross-examination, noticing the age of the landlady/eviction petitioner. It is submitted that the matter is now listed for [date withheld] and if given an opportunity, petitioner shall conclude the cross- examination on the same date. 3. Sh. Veer Chand has opposed the appeal. Preferring to the reply filed, it is submitted that no medical certificate of the illness of counsel was filed before the trial court on the said date and neither same has been filed in the present appeal. It is argued that the present respondent/eviction petitioner is 75 years old lady and deferment of the cross-examination was for the purposes of harassing her, who is an old lady. 4. I have heard learned counsels and perused the grounds of appeal and reply thereto. RCT no. 32/2023 Dharmender Tomar Vs. Kamla Devi Page 2 of 4 pages -- 2 of 4 -- 5. The averments as contained in para 8 (G) of the appeal as regards the chronology of the dates of hearing is not disputed in the reply filed by the present respondent. This court further has no reason to disbelieve the submissions made by Sh. Gupta at Bar that he was unwell on that date. Learned counsel has also placed on record printout of prescription by Dr. Yogesh Kumar Aggarwal recording that Sh. Ajay Gupta was suffering from fever and diarrhea. Sh. Gupta has also shown to this court order-sheets of the same date of the courts of Ms. Neetu Nagar, Learned ARC-02, Central, THC, Delhi and Sh. Ajay Gulati, Learned ADJ-01, Central, THC, Delhi wherein adjournments had been sought on his behalf and same was allowed on the same date, for the same reasons. 6. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, this court is of the opinion that non-availability of the counsel on 31.05.2023 before the court of Learned ACJ-cum ARC was justifiable. Moreover, considering that it was the only first date when subsequent to examination-in-chief, the witness who was the landlady herself, was sought to be recalled for further cross-examination; this court is of the opinion that one opportunity ought to be afforded to the present petitioner to conclude the cross-examination of the witness. Since the matter is stated to be listed on [date withheld], it is directed that on the date fixed, present respondent/eviction petitioner shall make herself available and the court shall afford an opportunity to the present petitioner to conclude the cross-examination. However, in case the date is not suitable to the court, one effective opportunity be afforded to present petitioner to conduct the cross-examination. RCT no. 32/2023 Dharmender Tomar Vs. Kamla Devi Page 3 of 4 pages -- 3 of 4 -- 7. Appeal is, accordingly, allowed. Impugned order dated 31.05.2023 is set aside with the directions as noticed above. 8. Copy of the order be sent to the learned trial court and file be consigned to records. Announced in the open court on this 26th day of July, 2023 (NAROTTAM KAUSHAL) Principal District & Sessions Judge (Central) Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi RCT no. 32/2023 Dharmender Tomar Vs. Kamla Devi Page 4 of 4 pages -- 4 of 4 --
