Full Order Text
Order 5 · 19 Mar 2026 · CNR DLCT010085342025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS DJ 710/25 :1: PYARE LAL Vs. ZAHEER AHMAD 19.03.2026 Present: Sh. Arun Kumar Singh, Sh. Arvind Kumar and Sh. Avinash Gautam, Ld. Counsels for plaintiff alongwith plaintiff in person. Sh. Mehmood Hassan, Ld. Counsel for defendant. 1. It is submitted by the plaintiff that he does not wish to file any replication and pleadings may be treated as completed. 2. There is a pending application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC filed by the defendant seeking rejection of the present plaint. 3. Submisisons on the application heard. Record carfully persued. 4. Rejection of the plaint sought on the ground that proper court fees has not been paid by the plaintiff as per law and the same is liable to be dismissed being barred by law. 5. On behalf of the plaintiff, a reply has been filed, wherein it is stated that for the relief of declaration, proper court fees has already been affixed as per law. Plaintiff has sought the relief of declaration of his title over the suit property as well as cancellation of documents put forth by the defendant regarding his ownership over the suit property. Since, plaintiff is not a party to the said documents allegedly executed in favour of the defendant and he is already in possession of the suit property and the consequential relief of possession has not been sought, he is liable to pay only a fixed court fees as per the Judgment of Apex Court in Suhrid Singh V. Randhir Singh Civil appeal No. 2811-2813/2010 decided on 29.03.2010. As regards the relief of damages of Rs. 10 lakh, it is submitted that plaintiff is willing to pay the court fees for the said relief. 6. Per contra, it is submitted by the defendant/applicant that -- 1 of 4 -- the value of the suit property is mentioned as Rs. 1 crore 47 lakhs in para No. 13 of the plaint and the consequential relief of injunction has been prayed and, accordingly, plaintiff is liable to pay court fees on the value of the suit property. Reliance in this regard has been placed upon the decision of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Jagdish v. Jaswinder Singh CS (OS) No. 2184/2009 order dated 22.12.2014. It is also submitted that plaintiff has himself pleaded in para No. 8 of the plaint that he is deprived of this peaceful possession of the suit property, which shows that he is out of possession and he has not sought the consequential relief of possession. Accordingly, the suit is bad in law. Reliance has been placed upon the decision of the Apex Court in Vidya Devi v. State of Himanchal Pradesh AIR (Online) 2020 SC 19, wherein the words deprived of the property have been interpreted to mean forcible dispossession of a person from his property. Accordingly, it is prayed that the plaint be rejected being barred by law. 7. I have heard the submissions made and carefully perused the record. 8. Section 8 of the plaint is re-produced herein under for the sake of clarity: “That it is submitted that the plaintiff is deprived of his peaceful possession of the above said properties since more than 3 months and has not been able to complete the construction work because it has been stopped by the police based on false claim based on fabricated documents filed by the defendant and as such the defendants are liable to pay damages for illegally stopping the construction over the above said properties/plots of Rs. 10,000,00/- for loss of building materials, labour, waste of other resources and harassment to the plaintiff till realization of suit.’’ 9. In my opinion the interpretation of this pleading of the -- 2 of 4 -- :3: plaintiff over that the defendant is interfering with his peaceful possession of the suit property because of which he is sustaining continuous losses as he is unable to complete the on going construction work in the suit property. Nowhere in the entire plaint, plaintiff has pleaded that he has been forcibly dispossessed by the defendant. The entire cause of action paragraph No. 12 of the plaint mentions the cause of action as and when the plaintiff was forced to stop the ongoing construction work in the suit property. Defendant, on the other hand, has alleged that he is in possession of the suit property in para No. 1 on reply on merits vide GPA sales agreement dated 28.08.2015 which are clearly hit by the Judgment of Suraj Lamps and Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana AIR 2012 SC 206. In these circumstances, the counter claims of the parties to the suit regarding their possession over the suit property become a disputed question of facts which can be decided only after appreciation of evidence led by the parties. At this stage, when the plaintiff is claiming himself to be in possession of the suit property, the suit cannot be rejected on the ground of being barred by law as the consequential relief of possession has not been sought. 10. As regards the payment of court fees on the relief of declaration, two counter judgments have been filed by the parties. The judgment relied upon by the plaintiff is that of the Apex court and has a binding effect on this court. The said judgment clearly holds that a person who is a non executant of a deed seeks a declaration or cancellation of the said deed without any consequential relief of possession, he is required to pay only a fixed court fees as has been paid by the plaintiff. Since, the question of possession over the suit property is a disputed question of fact, the proper payment of court fees in the facts and circumstances of the case also becomes a -- 3 of 4 -- mixed question of law and facts which can be decided only after appreciation of evidence led by the parties. As regards the relief of damages sought by the plaintiff, he is directed to pay the court fees thereon, on or before the NDOH. The remaining issue of court fees shall be decided after appreciation of evidence led by the parties. 11. In view of the reasons given above, at this stage, no ground is made out for rejection of the plaint. The application is accordingly dismissed. 12. Renotify for framing of issues on 11.05.2026. (Shivali Sharma) District Judge-06, Central Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi/19.03.2026 -- 4 of 4 --
