Full Order Text
Order 3 · 10 Sept 2025 · CNR DLCT010085342025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: Page no.1 CSDJ no. 710/25 Pyare Lal Vs Zaheer Ahmad 10.09.2025 Present: Sh. Arun Kumar Singh Ld counsel for plaintiff with plaintiff in person. Sh. Mahmood Hassan Ld counsel for defendant. Time is sought on behalf of plaintiff to file reply to the application u/o 7 rule 11 CPC. Let the same be filed within one week from today with advance copy to the opposite counsel. Arguments on the application u/o 39 rules 1 and 2 CPC heard. Put up for orders during the course of day. (Shivali Sharma) District Judge-06, Central Tis Hazari Courts 10.09.2025 at 1pm. Present: None. 1. Vide this order I shall dispose of an application under order 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC filed by the plaintiff. Arguments on the application have already been heard and record is carefully perused. 2. Brief facts of the case necessary for disposal of the -- 1 of 7 -- Page no.2 application under consideration are that plaintiff has filed the present suit against the defendant seeking declaration , mandatory and permanent injunction and damages alleging that he is the owner of properties bearing no. 3, 3A and 3B, Khasra no. 160, main Pusta road, nearby Kalighat, Wazirabad Village, Delhi-84 (hereinafter referred to Suit property) by way of GPA, agreement to sell and other documents dated 23.11.1992. It is specifically alleged in the plaint that plaintiff has remained in uninterrupted possession in the suit property since 23.11.1992 and had also made certain constructions there upon. In the year 2003, plaintiff had opened Dimple Public school for pre- nursery to 5th class. Unfortunately the school did not go well and had to be shut down. In 2017 plaintiff started a factory for manufacturing of ladies undergarments in the suit property but the said business shut down due to losses in 2018. Since 2019 the plaintiff is letting out the rooms constructed in the suit property . During assembly elections, an application for permission for opening party office of BSP in assembly constituency-AC-03 (Timarpur) was also approved by the ACP Delhi on 22.01.2025 in respect of the suit property. Electricity connection has also been taken by the plaintiff over the suit property and the latest electricity bill dated 08.05.2025 has been paid by the plaintiff. It is further alleged in the plaint that on 25.02.2025 plaintiff has -- 2 of 7 -- Page no.3 started demolition and some construction over suit property but on 20.05.2025 the said work was stopped by the defendant with the help of some goons. Defendant made a complaint dated 21.03.2025 to SHO, Wazirabad illegally claiming himself to be the owner of the suit property since 28.08.2015. The construction work was forcibly stopped by the defendant on 04.04.2025 on the basis of forged and fabricated property documents dated 28.08.2015. In this manner the plaintiff was deprived of his peaceful possession over the suit property by the defendant on the basis of forged and fabricated documents and he was unable to complete the construction work causing him loss of about Rs. 10 lacs. In these circumstances, plaintiff has filed present suit seeking reliefs of declaration declaring him to be owner of the suit property as well as declaring the alleged GPA dated 28.08.2015 in favour of defendant as null and void. Mandatory injunction has been sought for directing the defendant not to create any disturbance and disruption in construction over the suit property. Permanent injunction has been sought restraining the defendant from creating any third party right in the suit property. Damages to the tune of Rs. 10 lacs are also prayed. 3. Alongwith this plaint, plaintiff filed an application under 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC seeking a restraint against the defendant restraining him from letting, mortgaging, -- 3 of 7 -- Page no.4 alienating, transferring or creating any third party interest in the suit property. 4. The defendant filed his written statement wherein he alleged himself to be the owner and in possession of the suit property on the basis of GPA, agreement to sell and other documents dated 28.08.2015. All the allegations made against him in the plaint have been denied. In his reply to the application under order 39 rule 1 and 2 CPC, again the claim of the plaintiff has been controverted and dismissal of the application is sought. 5. I have heard the submissions made and carefully perused the record. 6. Plaintiff is claiming his ownership over the suit property on the basis of GPA, sales documents dated 23.11.1992 . In order to show his possession over the suit property multiple documents including the electricity bills as well as letter of ACP dated 23.01.2025 regarding permission for opening temporary party office has been placed on record. Per contra, the defendant is also claiming ownership over the suit property on the basis of GPA sales document dated 28.08.2015. Except for these GPA Sale documents, the defendant has not placed on record any document to show his possession over the suit property since 28.08.2015. It is simply argued that as per paragraph-8 of the plaint, the plaintiff has been deprived of his peaceful possession over -- 4 of 7 -- Page no.5 the suit property and accordingly, the present suit is not maintainable without seeking consequential relief of possession. 7. I have perused the entire plaint. The plaintiff has no where alleged that he has been ousted from the possession of the suit property. Rather his grievance is that he is not being permitted to enjoy peaceful possession over the suit property and continue the construction work there. This, in no manner, indicates that plaintiff is out of possession of the suit property when the documents showing his possession uptil May 2025 (electricity bill) have already been annexed alongwith the plaint. Moreover, the Apex Court has categorically held in Suraj Lamps and Industries Pvt Ltd V. State of Haryana, AIR 2012 SC 206, that the GPA sales documents are not sufficient to convey the title of any immovable property over a person. The documents of ownership relied upon by the defendant are pertaining to the year 2015 and are thus clearly hit by the decision in Suraj Lamps’ case (Supra). The plaintiff, on the other hand, is relying upon much prior documents pertaining to the year 1992. Thus, his case is on a much better footing than that of the defendant. 8. In view of the reasons given above, I have no hesitation in holding that considering the documents relied upon by the plaintiff in contradistinction to the documents of the -- 5 of 7 -- Page no.6 defendant, plaintiff has a good prima facie case in his favour. Balance of convenience is also lies in favour of the plaintiff and he is likely to suffer irreparable loss in case injunction is not granted in his favour as in case defendant succeeds in further selling the suit property on the basis of documents in his favour which are already under challenge, bonafide purchasers will be affected and it will lead to multiplicity of litigation affecting the claimed right of the plaintiff over the suit property. In these circumstance, I deem it appropriate to allow the application under consideration. 9. The application of the plaintiff under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC is, accordingly, allowed and defendant is restrained from letting, mortgaging, alienating, transferring or creating any third party interest in respect of any portion of the suit property i.e properties no. 3, 3A and 3B, Khasra no. 160, main Pushta road, near Kalighat, Wazirabad Village, Delhi-84 till disposal of the present suit/further orders. 10. With these directions application under consideration stands disposed off. 11. Nothing expressed herein shall tantamount to an expression of opinion on the merits of the case. 12. Plaintiff is directed to file replication within 30 days from today with advance copy to the opposite counsel. -- 6 of 7 -- Page no.7 13. Renotify for completion of pleadings, admission/denial of the documents, consideration of issues as well as arguments on the pending application under order 7 rule 11 CPC on 03.11.2025. (Shivali Sharma) District Judge-06, Central Tis Hazari Courts 10.09.2025 -- 7 of 7 --
