Full Order Text
Interim Order 15 · 22 Jul 2025 · CNR DLCT010057172025
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: CS DJ No433/25 Altaf Hussain vs Imran Baksh Page 1 of 4 IN THE COURT OF SH. SUMEET ANAND, DISTRICT JUDGE-11, CENTRAL DISTRICT, TIS HAZARI COURT, DELHI CS DJ No.433/25 Altaf Hussain Vs. Imran Baksh 22.07.2025 ORDER 1. Vide this order, this court shall decide and dispose off an application under Order I Rule 10 CPC seeking impleadment as defendant, moved by one Mohd. Abid. 2. The plaintiff has filed the present suit for damages, permanent and mandatory injunction against defendant, Imran Baksh. 3. It is the case of the plaintiff that he is proprietor of ‘Altaf Hussain & Sons’, and is running his business from shop no.5604, Katra Lachi Ram Dalal, Nai Sarak, Delhi-06. It is further the case of the plaintiff that the defendant no.1 is constructing property adjacent and behind his shop bearing no.5616, Gali Katra Jamun, Nai Sadak, Delhi. It is further the case of the plaintiff that the construction being carried out by the defendant no.1 is illegal and without sanction plan from the concerned authorities and the same has resulted in substantial damage to the property of the plaintiff, which has developed cracks and thereby become dangerous. 4. The Local Commission appointed by this court, in her preliminary report has also given her finding that indeed the construction is going on in the premises, as stated by the plaintiff -- 1 of 4 -- CS DJ No433/25 Altaf Hussain vs Imran Baksh Page 2 of 4 and major cracks have been developed in the premises of plaintiff. 5. Accordingly, restraining orders were passed by this court from carrying out any further construction by the defendant no.1. Thereafter, the application under disposal was filed. 6. The applicant in his application under disposal claims to be the rightful and authorized owner of the “part portion of property” bearing no.5616, situated at Nai Sadak, Katra Jamun, Chandni Chowk, Delhi-06. 7. The applicant in his application under disposal claims that he has acquired and purchased the “part portion” in the abovesaid property from one Sh. Ram Avtar Gupta and Sh. Hari Kumar Gupta vide registered sale deed dated 19.03.2025. The copy of the sale deed is annexed with the application. The applicant has also attached a site plan with his application under disposal. 8. It is the case of the applicant, as made out from his application under disposal, that, the plaintiff has unlawfully and without authorization encroached upon the subject property of the applicant thereby infringing upon the applicant’s exclusive right, ownership and possession, therefore, the actions of plaintiff are not only unauthorized but prejudicial to the applicant’s interest, therefore, the applicant prays for immediate intervention of the court in the present case to protect his interest, right and ownership in the subject property. 9. The plaintiff has filed reply to the application under Order I Rule 10 CPC opposing the same. -- 2 of 4 -- CS DJ No433/25 Altaf Hussain vs Imran Baksh Page 3 of 4 10. This court has perused the record and has carefully considered the submissions addressed by the parties in support, and against the application under disposal. 11. There are two site plans on record. One is Annexure-P1 filed by the plaintiff alongwith his plaint and another site plan is Annexure-C filed by the applicant alongwith his application under disposal. Accordingly to both the site plans, the property of the plaintiff and the shop no.5616, where the alleged unauthorized construction is being carried out by defendant no.1 are adjacent to each other. There is also no dispute about this fact. 12. The applicant does not claim to be the owner of entire property bearing no.5616, but as per his application, he claims to be only the owner of only part portion of the property no.5616, where alleged construction is going on. 13. Now, from his site plan filed alongwith his application, it is not clear that he is owner of which part of the property no.5616, whether his part is adjacent to the part of the plaintiff or not. On this very aspect clarifications were sought from ld. counsel for applicant and he orally submitted before the court that his is portion is exactly adjacent to the portion of the plaintiff, therefore, he seeks his impleadment in this case. 14. It is not the case of the applicant, as can be ascertained from the application under disposal that he is aggrieved by the case of the plaintiff seeking relief for illegal or unauthorized construction against the defendant no.1. It is also not the case of the applicant as the same is neither stated in his application under disposal nor pleaded orally during arguments -- 3 of 4 -- CS DJ No433/25 Altaf Hussain vs Imran Baksh Page 4 of 4 that he is aggrieved by the order of restraining the construction on the property of the defendant no.1. The claim of the applicant seeking impleadment in the present suit is that the plaintiff has unlawfully and without authorization encroached in his part of property, thereby infringing applicant’s right of ownership. 15. In the opinion of this court, the cause of action raised by the applicant may be a cause to bring the separate individual suit against the plaintiff but the same is no ground for impleadment of the applicant in the present suit. The violation of right to which the plaintiff is seeking remedy from this court by way of present suit; and the right which the proposed defendant, according to averments made in his application, seeks to agitate before this court are totally independent of each other. 16. Thus, the averments made by the applicant in his application under disposal under Order I Rule 10 CPC at no rate carves any ground for impleadment of applicant in the present suit. 17. Accordingly, the application under Order I Rule 10 CPC filed by Mohd. Abid is hereby dismissed. 18. Put up for further proceedings, particularly calling the status report from MCD in terms of previous orders. Order be signed digitally and uploaded online. Announced in the open court on 22.07.2025 (This order contains 4 number of pages) (SUMEET ANAND) District Judge-11, Central District, Tis Hazari Court, Delhi(s) -- 4 of 4 --
