Full Order Text
Final Order 7 · 19 Dec 2023 · CNR DLCT010048622023
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: CNR No. DLCT010048622023 IN THE COURT OF MS. ILLA RAWAT : DISTRICT JUDGE COMMERCIAL COURT- 03: (CENTRAL) : TIS HAZARI : DELHI. CS (COMM) No. 594/2023 In the matter of :- M/s Kiran Roadways Private Limited Through its AR, Sh. Dinesh Kumar Singh Office at: 7483, Bansal Apartment, 1st Floor, Tel Mill Marg, Ram Nagar, Paharganj, New Delhi-110055 ...Plaintiff Versus M/s Altech Infrastructure Private Limited Through its Managing Director – Sh. Amit Kumra Office at:- Plot No. 293, Kehar Singh Estate, West End Marg, Saidul Jab, New Delhi – 110030 Factory at: E-535 (A), Industrial Area Chopanki, Near Bhiwadi, District Alwar, Rajasthan - 301019. ...Defendant Date of Institution : 05.04.2023 Judgment reserved on : 19.12.2023 Judgment passed on : 19.12.2023 CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 1 / 7 -- 1 of 7 -- SUIT UNDER ORDER XXXVII OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908 FOR RECOVERY JUDGMENT 1. Plaintiff has filed a suit under Order XXXVII of Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as CPC) for recovery of Rs.25,57,600/- (Rs.16,57,600/- towards principal amount and Rs.9,00,000/- towards interest @ 18% p.a. w.e.f. January 2020 till the date of filing of suit) alongwith future interest @ 18% per annum from the date of filing of suit till its realization. 2. It is averred in the plaint that plaintiff is engaged in business of transportation under the name and style of M/s Kiran Roadways Pvt. Ltd. having its office at 7483, Bansal Apartment, 1st Floor, Tel Mill Marg, Ram Nagar, Paharganj, New Delhi- 110055. The defendants were having business dealing with plaintiff and had placed various orders for the transportation of material with the plaintiff company during the year 2019-2020. The plaintiff company transported the material of defendants in safe and sound condition and raised bills, as detailed in para 4 of the plaint, for a total sum of Rs.17,37,600/- out of which the defendants have made part payment of Rs.80,000/- through RTGS on 24.01.2020 and a sum of Rs.16,57,600/- remains outstanding towards the defendants. 3. It is further averred in the plaint that the defendant issued 09 post-dated cheques in favour of the plaintiff, as detailed in para 5 of the plaint, towards discharge of its liability. The CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 2 / 7 -- 2 of 7 -- plaintiff presented all of the said cheques, except one cheque bearing no.001497 dated 30.06.2020 for a sum Rs.57,600/-, for encashment before his banker but all the cheques were returned dishonored on 07.03.2020 with remark “Funds Insufficient/Account closed”. Thus a sum of Rs.16,57,600/- remained due and payable towards plaintiff by the defendants. Plaintiff sent separate legal notices, all dated 16.06.2021, but with no avail. The plaintiff thereafter initiated proceedings for pre-institution mediation, however, defendants did not join the same and thus a non-starter report dated 25.11.2021 was issued. Plaintiff has thus filed present suit praying for passing a decree of Rs.25,57,600/- (Rs.16,57,600/- towards principal amount and Rs.9,00,000/- towards interest @ 18% p.a. w.e.f. January 2020 till filing of the suit) alongwith future interest @ 18% p.a. from the date of filing of the suit till the realization of the decreetal amount. 4. Initially the plaintiff filed suit against defendant no.1 company as well as its director defendant no.2 but since defendant no.2 does not have any personal liability in business dealings with plaintiff, the plaintiff proceeded with suit against defendant no.1 company only and filed amended memo of parties dated 18.11.2023. 5. Summons of the suit were issued to the Defendant No.1 only as per order dated 05.07.2023. Summons were issued in Form No.4 of Appendix B as per Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub- rule(2) CPC. The service of the same was effected upon the Defendant at factory address through speed post vide receipt CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 3 / 7 -- 3 of 7 -- no.ED512305122IN and through registered post vide receipt no. RD806152363IN on 30.11.2023. The Defendant, however, did not file appearance within the period stipulated under Order XXXVII CPC. 6. Counsel for the Plaintiff stated that since the Defendant has failed to file appearance within 10 days, as required under Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub-rule (3) CPC, the judgment be passed in favour of the Plaintiff. 7. I have heard the learned Counsel for the Plaintiff at length and have also carefully perused the entire record and the relevant provisions of the law. 8. Since the summons for appearance issued to the Defendant were duly served upon it on 30.11.2023 through speed post and registered post, despite which no appearance was filed by the Defendant, as required under Order XXXVII Rule 3, sub- rule(1) CPC, the allegations in the plaint are deemed to have been admitted by the Defendant in view of the provisions contained under Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub-rule(3) CPC and the Plaintiff becomes entitled to a decree in its favour. 9. Order XXXVII Rule 3, sub-rule (1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is reproduced as under:- “3. Procedure for the appearance of defendant. - (1) In a suit to which this Order applies, the plaintiff shall, together with the summons under rule 2, serve on the defendant a copy of the plaint and annexures thereto and the defendant may, at any time within ten days of such service, enter an appearance either CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 4 / 7 -- 4 of 7 -- in person or by pleader and, in either case, he shall file in Court an address for service of notices on him. (2) to (7) xx xx xx” 10. Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub-rule (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 is reproduced as under:- “2. Institution of summary suits. - (1) xx xx xx (2) xx xx xx (3) The defendant shall not defend the suit referred to in sub-rule(1) unless he enters an appearance and in default of his entering an appearance the allegations in the plaint shall be deemed to be admitted and the plaintiff shall be entitled to a decree for any sum, not exceeding the sum mentioned in the summons, together with interest at the rate specified, if any, up to the date of the decree and such sum for costs as may be determined by the High Court from time to time by rules made in that behalf and such decree may be executed forthwith.” 11. The Plaintiff has placed on record following documents along with the Plaint:- i) Original Board Resolution dated 04.09.2021. ii) Memorandum & Article of Association of plaintiff. iii) Original cheques bearing No.001497 dated 30.06.2020 for Rs.57,600/-, 001498 dated 10.01.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001499 dated 31.01.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001500 dated 20.02.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001501 dated 11.03.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001502 dated 05.04.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001503 dated CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 5 / 7 -- 5 of 7 -- 25.04.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, 001504 dated 15.05.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/- and 001505 dated 08.06.2021 for Rs.2,00,000/-, all drawn on HDFC Bank, Lajpat Nagar-II, New Delhi, with return memos. iv) Copy of legal notice dated 23.03.2021 with postal receipt. v) Copy of legal notice dated 23.03.2021 with postal receipt. vi) Copy of legal notice dated 09.04.2021 with postal receipt. vii) Copy of legal notice dated 23.03.2021 with postal receipt. viii) Copy of legal notice dated 16.06.2021 with postal receipt. ix) Copy of legal notice dated 10.03.2021 with postal receipt. x) Demand letter dated 22.08.2020. xi) Returned envelops xii) Non-starter report dated 25.11.2022 issued by DLSA, Central District. 12. From the documents placed on record by plaintiff, it stand established that plaintiff had given services to defendant by transporting material and had done work worth Rs.16,57,600/- for which defendant made part payment of Rs.80,000/- on 24.01.2020 and gave 09 cheques worth Rs.16,57,600/- for the balance amount. All the cheques issued by defendant were returned back dishonored with remarks “Funds CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 6 / 7 -- 6 of 7 -- insufficient/Account closed”. Demand notices were also issued to the defendant despite which defendant failed to make payment of the outstanding amount. The defendant was further issued summons. The defendant, however, failed to put in appearance despite service of summons in Form No.4 of Appendix B as per provisions contained under Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub-rule(2) CPC. Accordingly, the suit of plaintiff is decreed in favour of plaintiff and against defendant, for a sum of Rs.16,57,600/-. Although plaintiff has prayed for a sum of Rs.9,00,000/- towards interest @ 18% per annum w.e.f. January 2020 till the date of filing of suit with future interest also @ 18% per annum from the date of filing till realization, the claimed rate of interest cannot be awarded to plaintiff as bills of transportation of material have not been placed on record by plaintiff, though so claimed in the plaint. Accordingly, the interest of justice would be served if plaintiff is granted simple interest @ 12% p.a. from 24.01.2020 i.e. the date of part payment till today i.e. 19.12.2023, the date on which decree is passed in terms of Order XXXVII Rule 2, sub-rule (3) of CPC. Costs of the suit are also awarded in favour of the plaintiff. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly. The suit under Order XXXVII CPC accordingly stands disposed off. File be consigned to record room after due compliance. Announced in the open Court on 19th December, 2023. (ILLA RAWAT) District Judge Commercial Court-03 Central District, THC, Delhi. CS (COMM) No.594/2023 Page No. 7 / 7 -- 7 of 7 --
