Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 9

CNR DLCT01004084202527 Jan 2026
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 9 · 27 Jan 2026 · CNR DLCT010040842025

Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT
Pdf Text: MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 1 of 29
IN THE COURT OF MS. RUCHIKA SINGLA
PRESIDING OFFICER, MACT-01 (CENTRAL)
TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI.
DLCT010040842025
MACT No. : 244/25
FIR No. : 512/2024
PS : Timarpur
u/s : 281/125 (B) BNS
Sh. Rohit Sharma
C/o Sh. Sahanser Pal Sharma,
R/o H. No. A-19, Gali No. 1, Block A,
TPDDL Office Himgiri Enclave, Burari
Delhi-110084.
…….Petitioner
VERSUS
1. Mr. Najeebul Arfin (DRIVER)
S/o Sh. Ghayasul Arfin
Present address H. No. 1676, Kucha Dakhni Rai,
Dariaganj, Delhi-110002.
Permanent Address. H. No. 540,
Gali Hakimji Choori Walan, Jama Masjid,
Chawri Bazar, Delhi-110006.
2. Mr. Faiz UI Arfin (OWNER)
Mr. Ghayasul Arfin
R/o H. No. 540, Gali Hakimji Choori,
Walan, Jama Masjid, Chawri Bazar,
Delhi-110006.
3. ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co.LTD. (INSURER)
-- 1 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 2 of 29
ICICI Lombard House,
414, Veer Savarkar Marg,
Near Sidhi Vinayak Temple,
Prabhadevi, Mumbai-400025.
.....Respondents
Date of filing of DAR : 19.03.2025
Judgment reserved on : 13.01.2026
Date of Award : 27.01.2026
A W A R D
1. The Detailed Accident Report (DAR) was filed on
19.03.2025 and was registered as a Motor Accident Claim petition. The
DAR revealed that a Road Traffic Accident took place on 05.10.2024, at
about 6:00 pm near Nirmal Hirday Church, Majnu Ka Tila, Delhi
wherein Sh. Rohit Sharma had sustained grievous injury. The accident
took place with the vehicle bearing registration No. DL5CV-3844 driven
rashly and negligently by respondent no.1, Najeebul Arfin, owned by
respondent no. 2 Faiz UI Arfin and insured with respondent no.3, ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd.
BRIEF FACTS
2. The brief facts that have emerged from the DAR are that on
19.03.2025, on receipt of information of an accident vide DD No. 96A,
the information of present accident was handed over to IO/PSI Jyoti
Yadav. She alongwith staff went to the Trauma Center, Civil Lines
where they collected MLC No. 2206/24 of the injured namely Rohit
Sharma. Thereafter, they came to know that injured had already left after
treatment. Then, the IO went to PS and made DD Entry of the
-- 2 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 3 of 29
information which was collected by them from the hospital. Thereafter,
IO along with staff went to the spot. No vehicle or eyewitness were
found from the spot. Thereafter, IO called the caller and he said that he
had already left.
3. On 06.10.2024, IO recorded the statement of the injured.
Thereafter, FIR was registered on the basis of statement of injured, DD
Entry and MLC under Section 281/125 (A) BNS. During the course of
investigation, IO prepared site plan at the instance of sister of injured.
No CCTV footage found from the spot. Further, notice u/s 133 MV Act
was served upon the owner of the offending vehicle and he replied that
at the time of the accident his brother Mr. Najeebul Arfin was driving
the said offending vehicle and the accident was occurred by his vehicle.
Thereafter, the owner produced vehicle and driver of the offending to
the IO of the present case. Further, IO took the documents and DL of the
offending vehicle into his custody and deposited them in the Malkhana.
Thereafter, IO interrogated the driver of the offending vehicle and
further he was arrested. As the offence was bailable, he was released on
bail. Further, mechanical inspection of both the vehicles were got
conducted.
4. Thereafter, IO got verified the documents from the
concerned authority which were found to be correct. Thereafter, MLC
was deposited in the hospital for final opinion and the injuries were
opined to be “grievous”. Upon this IO changed Section 125 (A) to
Section 125 (B) BNS. As the driver of the offending vehicle had fled
away from the spot, upon this IO added section 134/187 MV Act. After
-- 3 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 4 of 29
completion of investigation, chargesheet for the offences u/s 281/125(B)
BNS & 134/187 MV Act was filed against the driver of the offending
vehicle, Mr. Najeebul Arfin before the concerned Ld. JMFC and the
DAR was filed before this Tribunal.
WRITTEN STATEMENTS
5. WS was filed by the respondent no.1 & 2. It was stated by
the respondents that the accident was caused due to the rash and
negligent driving of the petitioner as he was driving his scooty at a fast
speed and he slipped and fell down. It was stated that the respondent
no.1 was driving his vehicle as per the traffic rules and regulations.
Hence, it is stated that the accident was not caused by the respondents
and they were not liable to pay any compensation to the petitioner.
6. Legal offer was filed on behalf of respondent no.3. It was
admitted that the offending vehicle was insured with the respondent
no.3 company vide policy No. 3001/357848579/00/B00 valid from
28.08.2024 to 27.08.2025. Legal offer to the tune of Rs. 40,000/- was
given but the same was not accepted by the petitioner.
ISSUES
7. On the basis of the pleading of the parties, vide order dated
15.07.2025, this Tribunal framed the following issues:
1. Whether the petitioner/injured suffered injuries in an
accident that took place on 05.10.2024 at about 06:00 pm
near Nirmal Hirday Church, Majnu Ka Tila, Delhi
involving vehicle bearing registration No. DL-5CV-3844
driven rashly and negligently by respondent no. 1
-- 4 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 5 of 29
Najeebul Arfin, owned by respondent no. 2 Faiz UI Arfin,
and insured with respondent no. 3 ICICI Lombard
General Insurance Co. Ltd.? OPP
2. Whether the petitioner/injured is entitled for
compensation? If so, to what amount and from whom?
OPP.
3. Relief.
EVIDENCE
8. Thereafter the matter was listed for PE. However, as Legal
Offer was filed by the respondent no.3, by implication, the factum of the
accident and the the rash and negligent act of the respondent no. 1 was
not disputed by the respondent no. 3. Hence, as the said facts are
admitted, the same were not required to be proved by the petitioner. In
these circumstances, Ld. Counsel for the petitioner stated that the award
may be passed on the basis of minimum wages as no proof of income of
the petitioner was available. Ld. Counsel for respondent no. 1 to 3 stated
that they had no objection to the same. Their statements were recorded
on 13.01.2026. Hence, no PE or RE was led by any of the parties.
FINAL ARGUMENTS
9. The Petitioner has filed his duly filled Form XIV and
financial statement of the injured was recorded. Final arguments were
heard on behalf of the petitioner and respondents.
FINDINGS & OBSERVATIONS
10. I have heard Ld. Counsel for the petitioner and Ld. Counsel
for respondents and perused the record. My findings on the various
-- 5 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 6 of 29
issues are as under:-
ISSUE NO.1:
Whether the petitioner/injured suffered injuries in an
accident that took place on 05.10.2024 at about 06:00 pm near Nirmal
Hirday Church, Majnu Ka Tila, Delhi involving vehicle bearing
registration No. DL-5CV-3844 driven rashly and negligently by
respondent no. 1 Najeebul Arfin, owned by respondent no. 2 Faiz UI
Arfin, and insured with respondent no. 3 ICICI Lombard General
Insurance Co. Ltd.? OPP
11. The onus to prove this issue was upon the petitioner.
However, perusal of record shows that legal offer was filed by the
respondent no. 3 in the present matter, meaning thereby, that the factum
of the accident and the the rash and negligent act of the respondent no. 1
was not disputed by the respondent no. 3. Hence, as the said facts are
admitted, the same are not required to be proved by the petitioner.
The injury:
12. The onus to prove the fact that the petitioner had suffered
injuries by way of the accident was upon the petitioner. In this regard,
the petitioner has relied upon his MLC bearing no. 13456/24 which is
part of the DAR. Perusal of the same shows that the petitioner was taken
to Lok Nayak Hospital on 05.10.2024 at about 06:20 pm with history of
road traffic accident. He sustained injuries in his head and leg. Then, he
has relied upon his treatment papers. His Discharge Summary issued by
Sant Parmanand Hospital is on record. Perusal of the report shows that
-- 6 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 7 of 29
he had suffered fracture in his leg. He was admitted in the hospital on
07.10.2024 and discharged on 09.10.2024. He was re-admitted in the
same hospital on 27.03.2025 and discharged on 31.03.2025. However,
as per this Discharge Summary, he was admitted in the hospital for the
treatment of pneumonia and not in furtherance of the accident. Hence,
the said Discharge Summary cannot be considered. However, he has
relied upon his Disability Certificate dated 09.10.2025 to prove that he
has suffered 31% permanent disability in his left lower limb.
13. In view of the above discussion, this Tribunal is of the
opinion that on the scales of preponderance of probabilities, the
petitioner has proved that the accident in question took place due to rash
and negligent driving of offending vehicle being driven by its
driver/respondent no. 1 on the date and time of the accident and that due
to the said accident, the petitioner had suffered grievous injury.
Accordingly, issue no. 1 is decided in favour of the petitioner and
against the respondents.
ISSUE NO. 2:
Whether the petitioner is entitled for any compensation? If
yes, to what extend and from whom? (OPP)
14. The onus to prove this issue was also upon the petitioner. In
view of the observations as given in issue no.1, the petitioner is entitled
for compensation. In the case of Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar & Ors.
(2011) 1 SCC 34, Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“General principles relating to compensation in
-- 7 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 8 of 29
injury cases
4. The provision of The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (`Act' for
short) makes it clear that the award must be just, which
means that compensation should, to the extent possible, fully
and adequately restore the claimant to the position prior to
the accident. The object of awarding damages is to make
good the loss suffered as a result of wrong done as far as
money can do so, in a fair, reasonable and equitable manner.
The Court or tribunal shall have to assess the damages
objectively and exclude from consideration any speculation
or fancy, though some conjecture with reference to the
nature of disability and its consequences, is inevitable. A
person is not only to be compensated for the physical injury,
but also for the loss which he suffered as a result of such
injury. This means that he is to be compensated for his
inability to lead a full life, his inability to enjoy those normal
amenities which he would have enjoyed but for the injuries,
and his inability to earn as much as he used to earn or could
have earned. (See C. K. Subramonia Iyer vs. T. Kunhikuttan
Nair - AIR 1970 SC 376, R. D. Hattangadi Vs. Pest Control
(India) Ltd. - 1995 (1) SCC 551 and Baker vs. Willoughby -
1970 AC 467).
5. The heads under which compensation is awarded in
personal injury cases are the following :
Pecuniary damages (Special Damages)
(i) Expenses relating to treatment,
hospitalization, medicines, transportation, nourishing food,
and miscellaneous expenditure.
(ii) Loss of earnings (and other gains) which the
injured would have made had he not been injured,
comprising :
(a) Loss of earning during the period of
treatment;
(b) Loss of future earnings on account of
permanent disability.
(iii) Future medical expenses.
Non-pecuniary damages (General Damages)
-- 8 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 9 of 29
(iv) Damages for pain, suffering and trauma as a
consequence of the injuries.
(v) Loss of amenities (and/or loss of prospects of
marriage).
(vi) Loss of expectation of life
(shortening of normal longevity).
In routine personal injury cases, compensation
will be awarded only under heads (i), (ii)(a) and (iv).”
15. In view of the above law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India, in injury cases, award needs to be passed only under
heads of medical expenses, loss of earning during treatment period and
damages for pain, suffering and trauma. This is a case where the
petitioner has claimed that he suffered grievous injury due to the
accident, hence, this Tribunal now proceeds further step by step to
decide the compensation/award under different heads applicable to the
present matter in light of above preposition.
Medical expenses:
16. The petitioner has claimed a sum of Rs. 86,447/- towards
medical expenses. However, bills to the tune of Rs. 1,32,600/- are
placed on record. One bill dated 11.04.2025 for Rs. 2,600/- shall not be
considered as there is no corresponding treatment bill and as the same is
after his admission in the hospital for pneumonia. Similarly, the bill no.
SIB0011409 dated 31.03.2025 for Rs. 46,153/- shall not be considered
as the same is for his admission in the hospital for pneumonia. Hence, a
sum of Rs. 83,847/- is granted to her under this head.
-- 9 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 10 of 29
Loss of income:
17. In this regard, the petitioner has alleged that at the time of
accident, he was working as a home tutor and was earning Rs. 30,000/-
pm. However, no evidence has been led to prove the same. Hence, it is
conceded that his income may be assessed as per the Minimum Wages
Act.
18. Perused.
19. The petitioner has filed his educational documents on
record. He has completed his B.A. from Delhi University. Hence, his
income shall be assessed as per the minimum wages payable to a
graduate. The date of the accident in the present matter is 05.10.2024.
Hence, as per the prevalent notification, Rs.23,836/- is ascertained to be
the monthly income of the injured.
20. It is stated that due to the said injuries, the petitioner was
unable to work since then. As per his medical records, he was admitted
in the hospital on 07.10.2024 and discharged on 09.10.2024. He has also
relied upon his Disability Certificate dated 09.10.2025. Hence,
considering the facts and circumstances, it can be said that the petitioner
may not have been able to work for three months at least. Accordingly,
the petitioner shall be entitled to loss of income for three months i.e. Rs.
23,836/- x 3 = Rs.71,508/-.
Special diet:
21. The petitioner is claiming a sum of Rs. 50,000/- towards
-- 10 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 11 of 29
special diet. Although, there is no bill to support his plea, but keeping in
view the nature of injury suffered by the petitioner and considering the
time of his treatment, it seems that he must have required special diet
and must have incurred expenditure towards special diet, therefore, a
sum of Rs. 30,000/- is awarded to the petitioner under the head of
special diet.
Conveyance charges:
22. The petitioner is claiming a sum of Rs. 50,000/- towards
conveyance charges. Admittedly there is no document showing expense
on conveyance, however, considering his injuries, this Tribunal is of the
view that the petitioner must have spent money on conveyance thus,
the petitioner is awarded a sum of Rs. 30,000/- towards conveyance
charges.
Attendant charges:
23. The petitioner has claimed Ra. 60,000/- under this head.
Admittedly there is no document showing expense on attendant.
However, considering the injuries of the petitioner, the petitioner is
awarded a sum of Rs. 25,000/- towards attendant charges .
Pain & Suffering:
24. The petitioner/injured has claim Rs. 1,00,000/- under the
head pain and suffering. It is not possible to quantify the compensation
admissible to petitioner for the shock, pain and sufferings etc. which he
actually suffered because of the above injuries, but as stated above, an
effort has to be made to compensate him for the same in a just and
-- 11 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 12 of 29
reasonable manner. Hence, keeping in view the extent and nature of the
injuries suffered by petitioner and duration of the treatment taken by him
etc., he is awarded a total amount of Rs. 50,000/- towards pain and
sufferings to the petitioner.
Mental and physical shock:
25. The petitioner/injured has claim Rs. 75,000/- for loss due to
mental shock. Keeping in view his injuries, it cannot be denied that he
would definitely have suffered mental agony. Hence, a sum of
Rs.50,000/- is awarded to the petitioner under head of “Loss due to
Mental & Physical Shock”.
Loss of amenities:
26. The petitioner/injured has claimed a sum of Rs. 1,00,000/-
under this head. Keeping in view his injuries, it cannot be denied that he
would definitely have loss of amenities. Hence, a sum of Rs. 50,000/-
is awarded to the petitioner under head of “Loss of amenities”.
Disfiguration
27. The petitioner/injured has claimed a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/-
under this head. Though the petitioner has suffered a permanent
disability, but there is nothing on record that he has suffered
disfiguration. Hence, a sum of Rs. 20,000/- is awarded to the petitioner
under this head.
Loss of earning, inconvenience, disappointment, frustration, mental
stress, dejectment and unhappiness in future life etc. & Loss of
-- 12 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 13 of 29
marriage prospects
28. Nil.
Loss of future earnings due to disability:
29. The petitioner has suffered a 31% permanent disability in
his left lower limb. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioner that due to
the said accident, he has lost his functional ability and unable to do
work. Hence, the petitioner has claimed loss of future earnings @ 16%.
30. Per contra, it is argued by Ld. Counsel for respondent no. 3
that the petitioner has suffered permanent disability in his leg and his
functional disability has to be considered in relation to his whole body.
He was working as a home tutor and the disability does not effect his
ability to teach students. Hence, he has not suffered any functional
disability.
31. In the case of Raj Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar & Ors. (2011)
1 SCC 34, Hon’ble Supreme Court held as under:
“Where the claimant suffers a permanent disability as a
result of injuries, the assessment of compensation under the
head of loss of future earnings, would depend upon the
effect and impact of such permanent disability on his
earning capacity. The Tribunal should not mechanically
apply the percentage of permanent disability as the
percentage of economic loss or loss of earning capacity. In
most of the cases, the percentage of economic loss, that is,
percentage of loss of earning capacity, arising from a
-- 13 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 14 of 29
permanent disability will be different from the percentage of
permanent disability. Some Tribunals wrongly assume that in
all cases, a particular extent (percentage) of permanent
disability would result in a corresponding loss of earning
capacity, and consequently, if the evidence produced show
45% as the permanent disability, will hold that there is 45%
loss of future earning capacity. In most of the cases, equating
the extent (percentage) of loss of earning capacity to the extent
(percentage) of permanent disability will result in award of
either too low or too high a compensation. What requires to
be assessed by the Tribunal is the effect of the permanently
disability on the earning capacity of the injured; and after
assessing the loss of earning capacity in terms of a
percentage of the income, it has to be quantified in terns of
money, to arrive at the future loss of earnings (by applying
the standard multiplier method used to determine loss of
dependency).”
32. Hence, the Tribunal has to examine as to how the disability
suffered by the petitioner affects his ability to earn. As per the
allegations of the petitioner, he was working as a home tutor. It has been
argued that due to his disability, he is unable to stand for long duration.
As argued by the Ld. Counsel for respondent no.3, the disability
suffered by the petitioner shall not affect his ability to teach students.
However, due to the said disability, he may be suffering discomfort in
travelling and standing for long hours. Hence, the functional disability
@ 16% is not unreasonable. The same is assessed to be 16%.
-- 14 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 15 of 29
33. This Tribunal has already assumed the monthly income of
petitioner to be Rs. 23,836/- at the relevant time. As far as the age of
petitioner at the time of accident is concerned, as per the petitioner's 10th
class marksheet, his date of birth is 09.12.1997. The date of accident is
05.10.2024. Hence, the age of petitioner as on the date of accident was
27 years. Therefore, in view of the law laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in case of Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation & Anr.,(2009) 6 SCC 121, which has also been upheld by
the Constitution Bench of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a recent
judgment dated 31.10.2017 given in the case of National Insurance
Company Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. SLP (Civil) No. 25590 of
2014, the multiplier of '17' is held applicable for calculating the loss of
future earnings of petitioner arising out of his above disability.
34. Further, by adopting the principles laid down in the case of
National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 2017 ACJ
2700 (SC), he shall be entitled to 40% future prospects as he was
less than 40 years of age at the time of accident. As already discussed
in the preceding para, the income of the petitioner has been taken as
Rs. 23,836/-. In view of the above, the loss of Income on account of
functional disability is calculated as under:
Monthly income Rs. 23,836/-
Annual Income Rs. 23,836/- x 12 =
Rs. 2,86,032/-
Add Future Prospects (40%) Rs. 1,14,412.80
Total income Rs. 2,86,032/- + Rs. 1,14,412.80 =
-- 15 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 16 of 29
Rs. 4,00,444.80
Disability @ 16% Rs. 4,00,444.80 x 16%= Rs.
64,071.16
Loss of Income after multiplier
(17)
Rs. 64,071.16 x 17 = Rs. 10,89,219.72
(rounded off to Rs. 10,89,210/-)
35. Thus, keeping in view the nature of injuries sustained by
the petitioner as well as the disability suffered by him, it is held that the
petitioner shall be entitled to Rs. 10,89,210/- under the head future
loss of income.
36. Accordingly, keeping in view the facts and circumstances,
the material on record, and the settled principles and guidelines
governing the injury cases like the present one, the compensation is
being derived in the present case as under:-
NAME OF HEAD AMOUNT (in Rupees)
Expenditure on Treatment Rs. 83,847/-
Monthly income of injured Rs. 23,836/-
Loss of income x 3 months Rs. 23,836/- x 3 = Rs.71,508/-.
Add future prospects 40%
Loss of future income (income X %
Earning Capacity X Multiplier)
Rs. 10,89,210/-
Any other loss/expenditure Nil
Expense on special diet Rs. 30,000/-
-- 16 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 17 of 29
Conveyance charges Rs.30,000/-
Attendant charges Rs.25,000/-
Mental & Physical Shock & Pain &
Suffering
Rs.50,000/- + Rs. 50,000/- = Rs.
1,00,000/-
Loss of amenities Rs.50,000/-
Disfiguration Rs.20,000/-
Loss of marriage prospects Nil
Loss of earning, inconvenience,
hardship, disappointment,
frustration, mental stress,
dejectment and unhappiness in
future life etc.
Nil
Total Rs. 14,99,565/-
37. In the case of Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Niru
@ Niharika & Ors. SLP no. 22136 of 2024 decided on 14.07.2025, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has upheld awarding of 9% interest per annum.
Therefore, it is held that the petitioner shall be entitled to interest @
9% per annum from the date of filing of DAR i.e. 19.03.2025 till
realization.
DISBURSEMENT
38. The Financial Statement of petitioner/injured was recorded
by this Court/Tribunal. As per the said statement, the monthly expenses
of his family are approximately Rs. 30,000/- to Rs. 35,000/- per month.
-- 17 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 18 of 29
39. The Hon'ble Delhi High Court vide orders dated 07.12.2018
& 08.01.2021 in FAO No. 842/2003 under the title Rajesh Tyagi &
Ors. Vs. Jaivir Singh & Ors. has given the following directions:
“(i) The bank shall not permit any joint name to be added
in the saving account or fixed deposit accounts of the
claimants i.e. saving bank accounts of the claimants shall
be an individual saving bank account and not a joint
account.
(ii) Original fixed deposit shall be retained by the bank
in safe custody. However, the statement containing FDR
number, FDR amount, date of maturity and maturity
amount shall be furnished by bank to the claimants.
(iii) The maturity amount of the FDRs be credited by the
ECS in the saving bank account of the claimant near the
place of their residence.
(iv) No loan, advance or withdrawal or premature
discharge be allowed on the fixed deposits without the
permission of the court.
(v) The concerned bank shall not issue any cheque book
and/or debit card to claimants. However, in case the
debit card and/or cheque book have already been issued,
bank shall cancel the same before the disbursement of the
award amount. The bank shall debit card(s) freeze the
account of claimants so that no debit card be issued in
respect of the account of claimants from any other
branch of the bank.
(vi) The bank shall make an endorsement on the
passbook of the claimant to the effect, that no cheque
books and/or debit card have been issued and shall not
be issued without the permission of the Court and the
-- 18 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 19 of 29
claimant shall produced the passbook with the
necessary endorsement before the Court for
compliance.”
40. However, in a recent judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India titled as Parminder Singh vs Honey Goyal on
18 March, 2025 in S.L.P. (C) No. 4484 OF 2020 has held that :
“17. The case in hand pertains to the compensation
awarded under the Motor Vehicles Act. The general
practice followed by the insurance companies, where the
compensation is not disputed, is to deposit the same
before the Tribunal. Instead of following that process, a
direction can always be issued to transfer the amount
into the bank account(s) of the claimant(s) with
intimation to the Tribunal.
17.1 For that purpose, the Tribunals at the initial stage of
pleadings or at the stage of leading evidence may require
the claimant(s) to furnish their bank account particulars
to the Tribunal along with the requisite proof, so that at
the stage of passing of the award the Tribunal may
direct that the amount of compensation be transferred
in the account of the claimant and if there are more
than one then in their respective accounts. If there is no
bank account, then they should be required to open the
bank account either individually or jointly with family
members only. It should also be mandated that, in case
there is any change in the bank account particulars of the
claimant(s) during the pendency of the claim petition
-- 19 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 20 of 29
they should update the same before the Tribunal. This
should be ensured before passing of the final award. It
may be ensured that the bank account should be in the
name of the claimant(s) and if minor, through
guardian(s) and in no case it should be a joint account
with any person, who is not a family member. The
transfer of the amount in the bank account, particulars of
which have been furnished by the claimant(s), as
mentioned in the award, shall be treated as satisfaction
of the award. Intimation of compliance should be
furnished to the Tribunal.”
41. In view of the same, the award amount can now be
disbursed in the Savings Bank Account of the petitioners. However, the
remaining directions as passed by the Hon’ble High Court shall be
complied with.
42. After considering the financial statement of the petitioner, it
is held that on realization of the award amount of Rs. 16,15,669/-
(Rupees Sixteen Lakhs Fifteen Thousand Six Hundred Sixty Nine
only), Rs. 3,15,669/- (Rupees Three Lakhs Fifteen Thousand Six
Hundred Sixty Nine only) be released to the petitioner/claimant
immediately in his bank account bearing no. 30395605311 at SBI Tis
Hazari, Delhi with IFSC Code SBIN0000726 CIF no. 85242166809.
43. The balance amount of Rs. 13,00,000/- (Rupees Thirteen
Lakhs only) shall be put in 26 monthly fixed deposits in her name in
-- 20 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 21 of 29
her bank account of equal amount of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty
Thousand only) each for a period of 01 month to 26 months
respectively, with cumulative interest, in terms of the directions
contained in FAO No. 842/2003 dated 07.12.2018 & 08.01.2021.
Besides the above said amount, amount of FDRs on maturity, shall
automatically be transferred in her saving account maintained in a
nationalized bank situated near the place of her residence.
44. In compliance of the directions given by Hon'ble High
Court in FAO No. 842/2003 dated 08.01.2021, Summary of the Award
in the prescribed Format-XVI is as under:
SUMMARY OF AWARD:
Date of Accident: 05.10.2024
Name of the Injured: Rohit Sharma
Age of the Injured: Presently 28 years
Occupation of the Injured: Home Tutor
Income of the Injured: Rs. 23,836/-
Nature of Injury: Grievous
Medical Treatment taken: LNJP Hospital, Delhi & Sant
Parmanand Hospital, Delhi
Period of Hospitalization: 07.10.2024 to 09.10.2024
Whether any permanent: Yes
disability?
-- 21 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 22 of 29
COMPUTATION OF COMPENSATION
Sr.
No.
Heads Awarded by the Claims Tribunal
1. Pecuniary Loss:
(i) Expenditure on Treatment Rs. 83,847/-
(ii) Expenditure on Special Diet Rs. 30,000/-
(iii) Expenditure on
Nursing/Attendant charges
Rs.25,000/-
(iv) Expenditure on Conveyance Rs.30,000/-
(v) Monthly income of injured Rs. 23,836/-
(vi) Loss of income x 3 months Rs.71,508/-
(vii) Add future prospects 40%
viii) Any other loss which may require
any special treatment or aid to the
injured for the rest of his life
Nil
2. Non Pecuniary Loss
(i) Compensation for mental and
physical shock Rs.50,000/- + Rs.50,000/- = Rs. 1,00,000/-
(ii) Pain and Sufferings
(iii) Loss of amenities of life Rs.50,000/-
(iv) Disfiguration Rs. 20,000/-
(v) Loss of marriage prospects Nil
(vi) Loss of earning, inconvenience,
hardships, disappointment,
frustration, mental stress,
Nil
-- 22 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 23 of 29
dejectment and unhappiness in
future life etc.
3. Disability resulting in loss of earning capacity:
(i) Percentage of disability assessed
and nature of disability as
permanent or temporary
31%
(ii) Loss of amenities or loss of
expectation of life span on
account of disability
Nil.
(iii) Percentage of loss of earning
capacity in relation to disability
16%
(iv) Loss of future income – (income
x % earning capacity x
Multiplier)
Rs. 10,89,210/-
4. Total
1(ii+iii+iv+vi)+2(i+ii+vi)
Rs. 14,99,565/-
5. Interest awarded 9%
6. Earlier award amount (which has
already been received by the
petitioner in terms of previous
award passed by Ld. Predecessor)
to be deducted from present
award amount .
-
7. Interest amount upto the date of
award w.e.f. 19.03.2025 till
realization
Rs. 1,16,103.31
9. Total amount including Interest Rs. 16,15,668.31 (rounded off to Rs.
16,15,669/-)
10. Award amount released As mentioned in para nos. 42 & 43
11. Award amount kept in FDRs As mentioned in para nos. 43
12. Mode of disbursement of the As mentioned in para nos.42 & 43
-- 23 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 24 of 29
award amount of the claimant(s)
13. Next date for compliance of the
award
27.02.2026
LIABILITY:
45. It has been established that the offending vehicle was being
driven by respondent no.1 and that respondent no.2 is the owner of the
same and the offending vehicle was insured with respondent no. 3.
Hence, it is directed that the respondent no. 3 shall be liable to pay the
compensation to the petitioner. Issue No. 2 is accordingly decided in
favour of the petitioner and against the respondents.
RELIEF:
46. The respondent no. 3 is directed to deposit a sum of Rs.
14,99,565/- (Rupees Fourteen Lakhs Ninety Nine Thousand Five
Hundred Sixty Five only) along with interest @ 9% from the date of
filing of DAR i.e. 19.03.2025 till realization with the Civil Nazir of
this Tribunal within 30 days under intimation to the claimant,
failing which the said respondent shall be liable to pay interest @
12% per annum for the period of delay beyond 30 days. Reliance
placed on case titled as Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Niru @
Niharika & Ors. SLP no. 22136 of 2024 decided on 14.07.2025 by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
47. Ahlmad is directed to e-mail an authenticated copy of the
award to the insurance company for compliance within the time granted
-- 24 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 25 of 29
as directed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in WP (Civil) No.
534/2020 titled as Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Pvt. Ltd. Vs.
Union of India & Ors. on 16.03.2021. The said respondent is further
directed to give intimation of deposit of the compensation amount to the
claimant and shall file a compliance report with the Claims Tribunal
with respect to the deposit of the compensation amount within 15 days
of the deposit with a copy to the Claimant and his counsel.
Ahlmad shall also e-mail an authenticated copy of the
award to Branch Manager, SBI, Tis Hazari Courts for information.
A digital copy of this award be forwarded to the parties
free of cost.
Ahlmad is directed to send the copy of the award to
Ld. Metropolitan Magistrate concerned and Delhi Legal Services
Authority in view of Central Motor Vehicles (fifth Amendment) Rules,
2022 [(Directions at serial nos. 39, 40 of Procedure for Investigation of
Motor Vehicle Accidents (under Rule 150A)].
Civil Nazir is directed to place a report on record on
27.02.2026 in the event of non-receipt/deposit of the compensation
amount within the time granted.
Further, Civil Nazir is directed to maintain the record in
Form XVIII in view of Central Motor Vehicles (fifth Amendment)
Rules, 2022 [(Directions at serial no. 41 of Procedure for Investigation
of Motor Vehicle Accidents (under Rule 150A).
Ahlmad is further directed to comply with the directions
passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in MAC APP No. 10/2021
-- 25 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 26 of 29
titled as New India Assurance Company Ltd. Vs. Sangeeta Vaid &
Ors., date of decision : 06.01.2021 regarding digitisation of the records.
File be consigned to Record Room after due compliance.
Announced in the open Court today
on this 27th January 2026.
(RUCHIKA SINGLA)
PO, MACT-01, CENTRAL DISTRICT,
TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI.
-- 26 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 27 of 29
THE PARTICULARS AS PER FORM-XVII, CENTRAL
MOTOR VEHICLES (FIFTH AMENDMENT) RULES, 2022
(PL. SEE RULE 150A) ARE AS UNDER:-
1 Date of Accident 05.10.2024
2 Date of filing of Form-I –
First Accident Report
(FAR)
08.10.2024
3 Date of delivery of Form-II
to the victim(s) 19.03.2025
4 Date of receipt of Form-III
from the Driver 25.11.2024
5 Date of receipt of Form-IV
from the Owner 25.11.2024
6 Date of filing of Form-V–
Particulars of the insurance
of the vehicle
25.11.2024
7 Date of receipt of Form-
VIA from the Victim(s) 19.03.2025
8 Date of filing of DAR 19.03.2025
9 Whether there was any delay
or deficiency on the part of
the Investigating Officer? If
so, whether any
action/direction warranted?
Yes
10 Date of appointment of the
Designated Officer by the
Insurance Company
19.03.2025
11 Whether the Designated
Officer of the Insurance
Company admitted his
report within 30 days of the
DAR?
Yes, Legal Offer
-- 27 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 28 of 29
12 Whether there was any delay
or deficiency on the part of
the Designated Officer of the
Insurance Company? If so,
whether any action/direction
warranted?
N/A
13 Date of response of the
claimant(s) to the offer of
the Insurance Company.
N/A
14 Date of award 27.01.2026
15 Whether the claimant(s)
were directed to open
savings bank account(s) near
their place of residence?
Yes.
16 Date of order by which
claimant(s) were directed to
open Savings Bank
Account(s) near his place of
residence and produce PAN
card and Aadhar Card and
the direction to the bank not
to issue any cheque
book/debit card to the
claimant(s) and make an
endorsement to this effect on
the passbook(s).
19.03.2025
17 Date on which the
claimant(s) produced the
passbook of their savings
bank account(s) near the
place of their residence
alongwith the endorsement,
PAN card and Aadhar Card?
N/A
18 Permanent residential
address of the claimant(s). As per Award.
-- 28 of 29 --
MACT No. 244/25 Rohit Sharma Vs. Najeebul Arfin & Ors. Page 29 of 29
19 Whether the claimant(s)
savings bank account(s) is
near their place of
residence?
N/A
20 Whether the Claimant(s)
were examined at the time of
passing of the Award to
ascertain his/their financial
condition?
Yes. The Financial Statement of the
claimant was recorded 13.01.2026.
(RUCHIKA SINGLA)
PO, MACT-01, CENTRAL DISTRICT,
TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI.
27.01.2026
-- 29 of 29 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.