Full Order Text
Interim Order 24 · 16 Mar 2026 · CNR DLCT010038062024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. MANOJ KUMAR-I, DISTRICT JUDGE (COMMERCIAL COURT)-05, CENTRAL, TIS HAZARI COURTS, DELHI CS (COMM) No. 359/2024 In the matter of: M/s Levi Strauss & Co. versus Rakesh Kumar and another ORDER This order shall decide an application under Order XI Rule 1(5) of the Commercial Court Act, 2015 (sic) read with section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) made on behalf of the plaintiff for placing on record document. 2. It is, inter alia, stated in the application that the present suit has been instituted by the plaintiff seeking reliefs against the defendant for infringement and passing off, along with an urgent application seeking ad-interim ex parte injunction; that in furtherance of the application under Order XI Rule 1(5) of the Commercial Court Act, 2015 (sic) read with section 151 of the CPC the plaintiff is now placing on record the photocopy of duly executed, notarized and stamped Power of Attorney in favour of the authorised representative of the plaintiff valid till December 31, 2025; that the following document could not be filed earlier due to the urgent circumstances surrounding the filing of the suit; that the Power of Attorney (valid till December 31, 2025) in favour Contd... -- 1 of 7 -- -2- of the authorized representative of the plaintiff was signed on 23rd of October, 2023; that the same was received in India by the authorized representative in New Delhi in December, 2023; that the said resolution cum authority letter in favour of Ms. Meena Bansal was executed in the United States on 23rd October, 2023 and in terms of section 18 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, any instrument executed outside Indian and first received in India is chargeable with stamp duty, which must be paid within three months of its receipt in India; that since the said instrument was not stamped within that period, it attracted the curative provisions of the Act; that the instrument was presented before the Collector of Stamps under section 40, and the Collector, treating the document as a Power of Attorney within the meaning of Article 48(b) of Schedule 1A (Delhi), determined the proper duty at 100/- and impose a penalty of ₹ ten times thereof, that is, 1,000/-, which has been duly paid on ₹ 04.12.2025; that the same was accepted by the learned Collector on 09.12.2025; that the delay, if any, in filing the aforesaid documents is bona file, unintentional, and solely attributable to the urgency and exigency in filing the suit at the earliest possible time to safeguard the plaintiff’s proprietary rights; that no prejudice would be caused to the defendant if the said document is now taken on record, whereas grave prejudice would be caused to the plaintiff if the same are not allowed to be placed on record; that the court has the inhering power under section 151 of CPC to permit the filing of such document and to take it on Contd... -- 2 of 7 -- -3- record in the interest of justice. It is stated that the application may be allowed and the photocopy of duly executed, notarized and stamped Power of Attorney in favour of the authorized representative of the plaintiff be taken on record. 3. Since the defendant No. 1 in the present suit is ex parte and the suit has been disposed of as settled against the defendant No. 2, therefore, no reply to the application has been sought. 4. I have heard counsel for the plaintiff and have gone through the material on record carefully. 5. Having drawn the attention of the court on the contents of the application and a document purporting to be copy of Power of Attorney dated 23.10.2023 executed in San Franciso, California, USA it is submitted by counsel for the plaintiff that the Power of Attorney, after execution on 23.10.2023 was received in India in the month of December, 2023 and the same was stamped as per the provisions of section 18 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 on 09.12.2025. It is further submitted by counsel for the plaintiff that the said document could not be filed on earlier occasion as the suit was filed on urgent basis, therefore, in the interest of justice, copy of Power of Attorney dated 23.10.2023 may be permitted to be filed. 6. I have given thoughtful consideration to the submissions made on behalf of the plaintiff. Contd... -- 3 of 7 -- -4- 7. The present suit under sections 134, 135, 29 & 27 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999, section 55 of the Copyright Act, 1957 for permanent injunction restraining infringement of trade marks and copyright, passing off, damages, delivery up etc, after filing, was received by way of assignment on 14.3.2024. Suit against the defendant No. 2 has already been decreed. Despite service of summons upon the defendant No. 1 none appeared on his behalf to contest the suit, therefore, by order dated 02.8.2024 he was ordered to be proceeded ex parte. During ex parte hearing qua the defendant No. 2 the plaintiff got examined PW1 Ms. Meena Bansal and thereafter evidence on behalf of the plaintiff was closed. When the case was at the stage of final arguments, the plaintiff made the present application. 8. Regarding filing of the documents in a commercial suit by a plaintiff, the relevant provisions of Order XI Rule 1 of CPC read as follows: 1. Disclosure and discovery of documents.—(1) Plaintiff shall file a list of all documents and photocopies of all documents, in its power, possession, control or custody, pertaining to the suit, along with the plaint, including:- (a) documents referred to and relied on by the plaintiff in the plaint; (b) documents relating to any matter in question in the proceeding, in the power, possession, control or custody of the plaintiff, as on the date of filing the plaint, irrespective of whether the same is in support of or adverse to the plaintiff’s case; (c) nothing in this Rule shall apply to documents produced by plaintiffs and relevant only–– Contd... -- 4 of 7 -- -5- (i) for the cross-examination of the defendant’s witnesses, or (ii) in answer to any case set-up by the defendant subsequent to the filing of the plaint, or (iii) handed over to a witness merely to refresh his memory. (2) The list of documents filed with the plaint shall specify whether the documents in the power, possession, control or custody of the plaintiff are originals, office copies or photocopies and the list shall also set out in brief, details of parties to each document, mode of execution, issuance or receipt and line of custody of each document. (3) The plaint shall contain a declaration on oath from the plaintiff that all documents in power, possession, control or custody of the plaintiff, pertaining to the facts and circumstances of the proceedings initiated by him have been disclosed and copies thereof annexed with the plaint, and that the plaintiff does not have any other documents in its power, possession, control or custody. Explanation.__A declaration on oath under this sub-rule shall be contained in the Statement of Truth as set out in the Appendix. (4) In case of urgent filings, the plaintiff may seek leave to rely on additional documents, as part of the above declaration on oath and subject to grant of such leave by Court, the plaintiff shall file such additional documents in Court, within thirty days of filing the suit, along with a declaration on oath that the plaintiff has produced all documents in its power, possession, control or custody, pertaining to the facts and circumstances of the proceedings initiated by the plaintiff and that the plaintiff does not have any other documents, in its power, possession, control or custody. (5) The plaintiff shall not be allowed to rely on documents, which were in the plaintiff's power, possession, control or custody and not disclosed along with plaint or within the extended period set out above, save and except by leave of Court and such leave shall be granted only upon the plaintiff establishing reasonable cause for non-disclosure along with the plaint. 9. The present suit has been instituted at the strength of documents, inter alia, a document purporting to be copy of Power of Contd... -- 5 of 7 -- -6- Attorney which has been marked as Ex.PW1/23 during the trial. 10. By way of the present application, the plaintiff wants to file another copy of Ex.PW1/23, but stamped as per provisions of Indian Stamp Act, 1899. A perusal of document sought to be filed reveals that it is a foreign document which was executed on 23.10.2023 and was to be effective from 01.01.2024 till 31.12.2025. As per the statements made in the application the said document was received in India in the month of December, 2023 and was not stamped before 09.12.2025, although the same was required to be stamped within three months of its arrival in India. After going through the contents of the application it cannot be said that the plaintiff was not in possession of the document or was not aware about the laws in India. The only excuse taken for non filing of the document is that the suit was filed on urgency basis. In the considered opinion of the court this is hardly a ground for accepting the document at this belated stage when the evidence on behalf of the plaintiff have already been led and the case is fixed for final arguments. The delay on the part of the plaintiff in not getting the document stamped as per law is self induced. The plaintiff cannot be allowed to take advantage of its own negligence, especially when another copy of the document has already been tendered in evidence as Ex.PW1/23. Even otherwise, as already mentioned, evidence in the case have already Contd... -- 6 of 7 -- -7- been led, and only by filing the document in question the same cannot be read in evidence. 11. It is also stated in the application that the document may be permitted to be filed in exercise of inherent powers. I am afraid in the face of the provision of Order XI Rule 1 (5) of CPC, this court, in derogation to the said provision cannot permit filing of the document. 12. In view of above discussion, as the plaintiff has failed to show any reasonable cause for filing the document at this stage, therefore, it cannot be permitted to file the said document. The application for filing of Power of Attorney dated 23.10.2023 is dismissed. Pronounced in the open court on the 16th day of March, 2026 (MANOJ KUMAR-I) District Judge (Commercial Court)-05 Central District: Tis Hazari: Delhi -- 7 of 7 --
