Full Order Text
Final Order 6 · 26 Sept 2024 · CNR DLCT010037562024
Order Details: COPY OF JUDGMENT Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. SUSHIL ANUJ TYAGI, ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE-04:CENTRAL, TIS HAZARI: DELHI. CNR No. DLCT01-003756-2024 CR No. 100/2024 1. Smt. Sneh Lata Jain W/o. Late Sh. Tarun Kumar Jain 2. Sh. Lovesh Jain S/o. Late Sh. Tarun Kumar Jain 3. Sh. Puneet Jain S/o. Late Sh. Tarun Kumar Jain All residents of : 3/8, Atur Rehman Lane Under Hill Road, Civil Lines, Delhi-54. …... Revisionists Vs. 1. Sunil Kumar Jain S/o. Sh. Kamal Chand Jain 2. Sh. Naman Kumar Jain S/o. Sh. Sunil Kumar Jain Both resident of : A-22, CC Colony, Opp. Rana Pratap Bagh, Delhi-110007. Also At : CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 1 of 9 -- 1 of 9 -- A-19, CC Colony, Opp. Rana Pratap Bagh, Delhi-110007. 3. Sh. Kailash Chand Jain S/o. Late Sh. Hira Lal Jain R/o. F-56, Preet Vihar, Delhi-110092. ...... Respondents Date of institution of Revision : 14.03.2024 Date on which order reserved : 07.09.2024 Date on which order pronounced : 26.09.2024 ORDER 1. This is a revision petition u/s. 397 Cr. P.C. challenging the impugned order dated 18.12.2023 of the ld. MM Sh. Chatinder Singh, (Central), Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, vide which the application u/s. 156 (3) Cr. P.C. as well as complaint under Section 200 Cr. P.C. of the complainant were dismissed. 2. The brief facts of the case which are necessary to decide the present revision petition are that the revisionists alleged that the respondent no. 1 Sunil Kumar Jain (real brother of the revisionist no. 1 and maternal uncle (mama) of revisionist no. 2 and 3), respondent no.2 Naman Kumar (nephew of revisionist no.1), respondent no.3 Kailash Chand Jain (uncle of revisionist no.1) have forged and fabricated the signatures of revisionist no.1, Smt. Kusum Kumari Jain (deceased mother in law of the CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 2 of 9 -- 2 of 9 -- revisionist no.1) and late Sh. Tarun Kumar Jain (husband of revisionist no.1) on one document allegedly executed on 20.12.2017 wherein it is mentioned that 35,000 shares of revisionist no. 1 and 40,000 shares of late Smt. Kusum Kumari Jain have been transferred to respondents Sunil Kumar Jain and Naman Kumar Jain. It is further alleged that the said documents came in the knowledge of the complainants, when the civil suit bearing no. 932/2019 titled as Sunil Kumar Jain vs. Smt. Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. was filed and the complainants were served the forged and fabricated documents. 3. The revisionists accordingly filed one complaint u/s. 200 Cr. P.C. alongwith an application u/s. 156 (3) Cr. P.C. against the accused persons, however, vide impugned order, the ld. Trial Court dismissed the application and the complaint on the ground that the complaint is hit by Sec. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. as the cognizance can only be taken on the complaint of the Court concerned. 4. It is contended by ld. Counsel for revisionists that embargo u/s. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. is not applicable to the facts of the present case as the documents were first forged and then filed in the Court. It is further contended that the impugned order passed by the ld. Trial Court is against the law and is liable to be set aside. To support his contentions, ld. Counsel has relied upon the following judgments:- (a) Sachida Nand Singh and Anr. Vs. State of Bihar and Anr., 1998 CRI. L.J. 1565 CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 3 of 9 -- 3 of 9 -- (b) Iqbal Singh Marwah and Anr. Meenakshi Marwah and Anr., decided 11.03.2005 (c) Ashok Gulabrao Bondre vs. Vilas Madhukarrao Deshmukh and Ors. 5. To the contrary, ld. Counsel for respondents contended that there is no error in the impugned order passed by the ld. Trial Court. It is further contended that the dispute, if any between the parties is purely civil in nature and the revisionists are attempting to give it a criminal colour. It is further contended that the respondents have committed perjury by forging signatures, however, admittedly, the revisionists have not preferred any application u/s. 340 Cr. P.C. till date in the suit filed by the respondents. It is further contended that the respondents and revisionists are closely related to each other and the revisionists have admitted the receipt of Rs. 1 Crore from the respondents and to avoid the refunding the money, it has been alleged that the same was gift and investment in business. It is further contended that there is no merit in the revision petition and the same may kindly be dismissed. 6. This Court has heard the rival submissions and perused the judicial record. 7. It is pertinent to refer to the relevant extracts of Sec. 195 (1) (b) Cr. P.C. which reads as follows:- “No Court shall take cognizance- Of any offence described in Sec. 463, or punishable u/s. 471, Sec. 475 or Sec. 476, of the said Court, when such offence is alleged to have been committed in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any Court, CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 4 of 9 -- 4 of 9 -- except on the complaint in writing of that Court, or some other Court to which that Court is subordinate.” 8. As Sec. 340 (1) Cr. P.C. has an interlink with Sec. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C., it is also necessary to refer the said sub- section which reads as follows:- “When upon an application made to it, in this behalf or otherwise, any Court is of the opinion that it is expedient in the interest of justice that an inquiry should be made into any offence referred to in cl. (b) of sub. Section. (1) of Sec. 195, which appears to have been committed in or in relation to a proceeding in that Court, or as the case may be, in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in that Court, such Court may, after such preliminary inquiry, if any, as it thinks necessary,- (a) record a finding to that effect; (b) make a complaint thereof in writing; (c) send it to a Magistrate of the first class having jurisdiction; (d) take sufficient security for the appearance of the accused before such Magistrate, or if the alleged offence is non bailable and the Court thinks it necessary so to do, send the accused in custody to such Magistrate, and (e) bind over any person to appear and give evidence before such Magistrate.” 9. Section 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. provides that Court shall not take cognizance regarding the offence of forgery in respect of a document produced or given in evidence in proceeding before any Court except on the written complaint of the Court. Section 340 Cr. P.C. provides the procedure to be followed in case such complaint is filed by the Court. CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 5 of 9 -- 5 of 9 -- 10. In the present case, the moot question that arises for the consideration of this Court is whether the bar u/s. 195 (1) (b) Cr. P.C. read with Sec. 340 Cr. P.C. would arise with respect to the alleged forged documents which were filed by respondents in the suit bearing CS/DJ No. 932/2019 before the ld. Civil Court and whether the private complaint case for the alleged offence is maintainable or not. 11. Section 195 Cr. P.C. has the heading which reads as “ Prosecution for contempt of lawful authority of public servants, for offences against public justice and for offences relating to documents given in evidence.” There could be two instances with respect to the offences in relation to the documents given in evidence. First, the document alleged to have been forged prior to them being filed in the Court and second, the documents which are forged while they were in custody of the Court. 12. As far as the second instance is concerned i.e. the documents which are in the custodia legis, if forged, there is no doubt that bar of Sec. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. would arise and the cognizance of such offence could only be taken on the written complaint of the Court and the procedure laid down in Sec. 340 Cr. P.C. is to be followed. 13. However, if the documents are forged prior to them being filed in the Court, then it is difficult to accept the contention that the bar of Sec. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. would apply. The reason is obvious. If the bar was to apply on CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 6 of 9 -- 6 of 9 -- such documents then it will add to the mischief. In other words, the mischievous person will file the forged documents in the Court and will avoid the private criminal prosecution claiming a bar of Sec. 195 (1)(b) Cr. P.C. It is settled law that a statute can not be interpreted in a manner which would enhance the mischief. 14. The three judges bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Sachida Nand Singh Vs. State of Bihar, 1998 Cri.Lj 1565, after analysis of the relevant provisions and noticing a number of earlier decisions, recorded its conclusion that the bar contained in Sec. 195 (1)(b) (ii) Cr. P.C. of the Code is not applicable to a case where forgery of a document was committed before the document was produced in the Court. It was observed thus:- “11. The scope of preliminary inquiry envisaged in Section 340(1) of the Code is to ascertain whether any offence affecting administration of justice has been committed in respect of a document produced in Court or given in evidence in a proceeding in that court. In other words, the offence should have been committed during the time when the document was in custodia legis. 12. It would be a strained thinking that any offence involving forgery of a document if committed outside the precincts of the court and long before its production in the court, could also be treated as one affecting administration of justice merely because that document later reached the court records. * * * * * 23. The sequitur of the above discussion is that the bar contained in Section 195 (1)(b) (ii) of the Code is not applicable to a case where forgery of the document was committed before the document was produced in the court.” CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 7 of 9 -- 7 of 9 -- 15. The five judges bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in landmark case titled as Iqbal Singh Marwah and Anr. Vs. Meenakshi Marwah and Anr, (2005) 4 SCC 370, affirmed the law laid down in Sachida Nand Singh case (Supra) and observed as follows:- “33. In view of the discussion made above, we are of the opinion that Sachida Nand Singh has been correctly decided and the view taken therein is the correct view. Section 195 (1)(b) (ii) Cr. P.C. would be attracted only when offence enumerated in the said provision have been committed with respect of a document after it has been produced or given in evidence in a proceeding in any court i.e. during the time when the document was in custodia legis.” 16. Now, adverting back to the present case, the alleged forged documents have been filed by respondents in the Court subsequently. It is not the case of the revisionists that any offence as enumerated in Sec. 195 (1)(b)(ii) Cr. P.C. was committed in respect to the alleged documents after they have been produced or filed in the civil court. Therefore, the bar created by Section 195 (1)(b)(ii) Cr. P.C. would not come into play and there is no embargo on the power of the Court to take cognizance of the offence on the basis of private complaint filed by the revisionists. 17. The ld. Trial Court while passing the impugned order dated 18.12.2023 committed palpable error in observing that the private complaint of the revisionist is hit by 195 Cr. P.C. Accordingly, the impugned order is hereby set aside. CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 8 of 9 -- 8 of 9 -- 18. The revision is allowed and the ld. Trial Court is directed to proceed with the case as per law. 19. Copy of this order be sent to the ld. Trial Court for information and necessary action. Pronounced in open court on 26th day of September, 2024 (SUSHIL ANUJ TYAGI) Additional Sessions Judge-04, Central, Delhi, THC, Delhi. CR No. 100/2024 Sneh Lata Jain and Ors. vs. Sunil Kumar Jain and Ors. Page No. 9 of 9 -- 9 of 9 --
