Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 03 Feb 2026 · CNR DLCT010021412026
Order Details: COPY OF JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS Pdf Text: T . P (Criminal ) No. 25/2026 Adnan Ashraf vs State 03.02.2026 Fresh transfer petition under Section u/s. 448 of BNSS filed. It be checked and registered. Present: Ms. Esha Sharma, Ld. Counsel for applicant. Present transfer petition has been filed seeking transfer of case bearing no. 949/2018, title State vs Adnan Ashraf & Ors, (FIR No. 225/18 PS Darya Ganj) from the court of Ms. Priyanka Bhagat, Ld. ASJ (SC-RC), Central, Delhi. The grievance has been raised on behalf of applicant that on 15.10.2025, Ld ASJ imposed the cost of Rs.10,000/- upon the applicant/ accused. On 24.01.2026, the matter was fixed for evidence but the adjournment was sought as main Counsel appearing for the applicant / accused was not well due to severe knee injury and an application seeking deferral of cross examination was moved on 19.01.2026. On 24.01.2026, accused Adnan Ashraf was directed to pay previous cost of Rs.5000/- without deciding the application for waiver of cost. Further, additional cost of Rs.3,000/- was imposed upon the accused. Ld. ASJ has also taken documents, articles etc on judicial record provided by the prosecutrix which are not part of the original or supplementary charge-sheet. The prosecutrix has sought adjournment and exemption on continuous dates. -- 1 of 3 -- The bias and prejudice is attributed to the Ld. Judge. Heard. Considered. The power to transfer, withdraw or assignment of the matters is discretionary but discretion must be exercised judiciously and on well founded reasons. When a matter is transferred from one court to another, on the basis of apprehension of bias, it has larger repercussions. The transfer cannot be allowed on flimsy grounds as also law is well settled in this regard. In The judgment of Madan Lal vs CBI /ACU- III,2004 SCC Online P & H 612, it has been observed as under:- 13. The law is well settled that a litigant cannot choose a Bench of his choice. It is only in exceptional circumstances where the existence of "bias" or "; likelihood of bias", when apparent on the facts and circumstances of a case that the High Court invokes its discretionary powers under Section 407, Cr .PC to transfer the trial of such case to another Court of Competent Jurisdiction, In the absence of an allegation of pre-existing bias, the power to transfer a case can be invoked only sparingly. Now-a-days, there is growing tendency amongst disgruntled litigants, often -- 2 of 3 -- ill advised, just to hoodwink the court. The allegations levelled by such litigants, therefore, need to be scrutinized with utmost care and circumspection. It cannot be overlooked that transferring a case merely on the asking of an apprehensive litigant would not only lead to scandalizing the Court but browbeating the Presiding Officer also, thereby causing direct interference in the independent and fair administration of justice. Judicial orders are open to scrutiny by higher courts and just because some orders are against a particular side, cannot be a ground to transfer the case. The litigants cannot be permitted to seek the transfer in order to avoid a strict judge or unfavourable orders. Having considered the material placed on record and rival contentions, I am of the opinion that this is not a fit case for allowing transfer of the case to any other court. Accordingly, transfer application is dismissed. File be consigned to the record room. (Anju Bajaj Chandna) Principal District & Sessions Judge (Central) Delhi/03.02.2026 -- 3 of 3 --
