Full Order Text
Interim Order 8 · 04 Feb 2026 · CNR DLCT010015232024
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: 11 CS DJ 120/24 Dilip Singh Vs. Sushil Kumar 04.02.2026 Pr.: Sh. Vineet Gandhi, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. Defendant no. 1 with Sh. Manoj Loomba and Sh. Vansh Chawla, Ld. Counsels for defendant no. 1. Defendants no. 2 and 4 are not contesting the case in view of the statement dated 06.02.2025. Defendant no. 3, 5, 6 & 7 are ex-parte. Steps not taken for the service of defendant no. 8 despite directions. Accordingly, plaintiff is hereby burdened with the cost of Rs.2,000/- to be deposit in DLSA for delaying the case. Receipt It is submitted on behalf of plaintiff that defendant no. 8 has given assurance that he will appear through VC. (PANKAJ ARORA) District Judge-16, Central Distt., Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, 04.02.2026 At Second Call: Pr.: Sh. Vineet Gandhi, Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff. Defendant no. 1 with Sh. Manoj Loomba and Sh. Vansh Chawla, Ld. Counsels for defendant no. 1. Defendants no. 2 and 4 are not contesting the case in view of the statement dated 06.02.2025. Defendant no. 3, 5, 6 & 7 are ex-parte. At this stage, Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has stated that one speed post envelope has been sent by defendant no. 8, however, Ahlmad of this -- 1 of 5 -- Court reports that one speed post envelope received, but the same is blank. Arguments on application u/O. 7 Rule 11 CPC heard. Put up for Orders at 4.00 p.m. (PANKAJ ARORA) District Judge-16, Central Distt., Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, 04.02.2026 At 4.00 p.m.: Pr.: None. Vide this order, this Court shall proceed to decide an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC moved on behalf of defendant no. 1. It is submitted on behalf of the defendant that the father of the applicant/defendant no. 1, during his lifetime, had partitioned the properties, by virtue of which the applicant/defendant no. 1 received the said property and the plaintiff received his share from the property situated at Pathankot, Punjab. The plaintiff is now taking advantage of the absence of both parents and is falsely deposing before this Court, thereby misleading the Court by suppressing material facts. The plaintiff has failed to disclose any cause of action, as he is relying upon a complaint which was filed by him after obtaining forceful signatures of the mother on blank papers. The plaintiff, in paragraph no. 14 of the plaint, has stated that he has paid the requisite court fees for the relief sought. It is submitted that upon inspection of the file, the said averment regarding payment of requisite court fees is found to be vague, as the plaintiff has only affixed a court fee of Rs. 50/-, which is clearly -- 2 of 5 -- reflected on page ‘A’ of the plaint and further in the checklist. It is submitted that it is settled law that the plaintiff has to seek partition of all the joint family properties and also disclose the details thereof. Ld. counsel for the defendant has filed the following authorities in support of his contentions: * Sri K. R. Ravishankar vs. Smt. Vijayamma, decided by the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka on 26.10.2023 * Hiralal vs. Nandlal & Ors., decided by the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay Bench on 24.10.2024 * Kenchegowda vs. Siddegowda @ Motegowda, JT 1994 (4) SC 125 On the other hand, the application is strongly opposed on behalf of the plaintiff by filing a reply. It is submitted that the suit property has never been partitioned. The father of the plaintiff had only partitioned the property situated in Punjab through a Will dated 14.02.2008. A copy of the said Will, along with its true Hindi translation, is annexed with the reply. Arguments have already been heard. Record perused. It is well settled that, in order to ascertain the cause of action, only the averments made in the plaint are to be looked into, and the defence set up by the defendants cannot be considered. The plaintiff has filed the present suit seeking partition of the property situated at B-355, Nehru Vihar, Delhi-110054. It is not in dispute that the father of the plaintiff and defendants no. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5, was the erstwhile owner of the suit property. It is also well settled that there is a strong presumption in respect of registered documents. As per the claim of the plaintiff, the property situated in Punjab has already been partitioned vide registered -- 3 of 5 -- Will dated 14.02.2008 and, therefore, he is not required to claim partition of the said property. It is further noted that no relief of possession has been sought by the plaintiff, and it is expressly stated in paragraph no. 14(a) of the plaint that the plaintiff is in possession of the third floor of the suit property along with the terrace. Therefore, the plaintiff is not required to pay ad-valorem court fees and he is required to pay only fixed court-fees as per Article 17 (vi) of Schedule II of the the Court Fees Act, 1870. A division bench of Delhi High Court in Saroj Salkan vs Sanjeev Singh 155 (2008) DLT 300 (DB) has held that “ It is settled law that in a suit for partition, the court fees to be paid if joint possession is pleaded by the plaintiff on the basis that he is the co-owner of the property sought to be partitioned, fixed court fees would be payable under Article 17(vi) of Schedule II of the Court Fees Act presuming the joint possession of the plaintiff even if the plaintiff is not in actual possession. It is because of the reason that in the case of co- owners, the possession of one is in law possession of all, unless from the averments in the plaint read as a whole, a clear case of ouster is made and in that situation the plaintiff is liable to pay ad-valorem court fees on the market value of this share as provided under Section 7 (iv)(b) of the Court Fees Act notwithstanding the fact that it is also pleaded that the plaintiff was in constructive possession.”. Whether or not plaintiff is required to reveal the details of joint family property situated in Punjab, which is claimed to have been already partitioned vide Will dated 14.02.2008, is a matter of trial and evidence. The authorities relied upon by the defendant are not applicable in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case. -- 4 of 5 -- Accordingly, the application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC moved on behalf of defendant no. 1 stands dismissed. The plaintiff is directed to take steps for service of defendant no. 8 and issue summons for settlement of issues upon him through all possible modes, including electronic modes, on filing of PF and RC, Put up for filing of service report of defendant no. 8 on 03.03.2026. (PANKAJ ARORA) District Judge-16, Central Distt., Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi, 04.02.2026 -- 5 of 5 --
