Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 21 Apr 2023 · CNR DLCT010012642023
Order Details: COPY OF ORDER Pdf Text: IN THE COURT OF SH. DHARMENDER RANA ASJ/SPECIAL JUDGE, NDPS ACT (CENTRAL): TIS HAZARI COURTS: DELHI In the matter of:- CR NO. 57/2023 CNR NO. DLCT01-001264-2023 Anmol Khurana S/o Sh Vikas Khurana R/o H No. 2375, Hudson Lane, Kingsway Camp, Delhi-110009. ........ Revisionist VERSUS The State Through the Station House Officer Police Station Daryaganj …........Respondent Date of institution of Revision petition : 27.01.2023 Date of arguments : 20.04.2023 Date of Order : : 21.04.2023 Final order: : Dismissed O R D E R By way of the instant order I shall dispose of the revision petition filed by Sh. Anmol Khurana (hereinafter referred as revisionist) assailing the order dated 15.10.2022, whereby the Ld. Trial Court has framed charges against the revisionist for commission of offence under Section 279/304A IPC and under Section 134A/187 MV Act. Briefly Stated: 1. The revisionist herein is facing trial in case FIR No. 221/2018, PS Darya Ganj, alleging the commission of offence under Section 279/304A IPC and under Section 134A/187 MV CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.1/6 -- 1 of 6 -- Act. 2. During the course of trial, vide impugned order dated 15.10.2022 the Ld. Trial Court directed framing of charges/notice against the revisionist for the abovementioned offences, hence, the instant revision. The instant revision petition is accompanied with an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act seeking condonation of delay of 75 days in filing the instant revision petition. The revisionist is seeking condonation of delay on following twin grounds: (i) The impugned order was uploaded after the delay of about 15 days. (ii) That the revisionist has filed Criminal MC No. 418/2023 against the impugned order before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court under a bonafide belief that the remedy lies under Section 482 CrPC. 3. In my opinion, the revision petition is hopelessly time barred and none of the reasons cited by the Ld. Counsel of revisionist are convincing enough justifying the condonation of delay. There is nothing on record to suggest that the impugned order could not be procured as the order was not ready on 15.10.2022. The revisionist has failed to place on record any evidence to the effect that he has applied for the certified copies of the impugned order, well in time, but the same was not provided to him as the order was not ready. Rather to the contrary till date the certified copy of the impugned order has not been placed on record. The statutory presumption under Section 114 Indian Evidence Act operates against the revisionist and a very heavy CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.2/6 -- 2 of 6 -- onus lies upon him to rebut the presumption that the judicial acts are not been regularly performed and the order dated 15.10.2022 was not ready on the date when it was pronounced. In the absence of anything to be contrary, it cannot be presumed that the order was not ready on 15.10.2022 and an unprepared order or an incomplete order was pronounced on 15.10.2022. The contention in the teeth of the court record is found to be absolutely meritless and is taken on record to be rejected. 4. Further, even the period consumed in Criminal MC No. 418/2023 shall not come to the rescue of the revisionist as he has himself informed the court that he filed the said petition before the Hon'ble Delhi High Court on 19.01.2023 whereas the limitation period has already expired on 14.01.2023 itself. Therefore, there is no justifiable ground brought to my notice permitting this court to condone the delay of 75 days in the instant matter. 5. Further, even on merits the revisionist has no case. Ld. Counsel is assailing the impugned order on the following grounds:- (i) It is pointed out that the MLC of deceased Shoaib reflects that he was brought to the hospital by one Guddiya, whereas in the list of witnesses of the prosecution it is claimed that he was brought to the hospital by one para-medix staff in the CATS ambulance namely Roshan. Further, it is also pointed out that the MLC states that the injured was still conscious and has collapsed in the hospital at the time of transferring whereas as per the prosecution case he has expired before he reached the hospital. (ii) The eye witness/complainant namely Sikander is a planted CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.3/6 -- 3 of 6 -- witness as he claims that he was washing motorcycle at the time of accident on NH-48 but the spot of the accident is inaccessible from ground level even for a person who is athletically gifted. (iii) It is submitted that the postmortem report reflects the cause of death due to blunt force trauma but no conclusive opinion is reflected in the postmortem report and it is merely an assumption. (iv) There are numerous contradictions in the victim impact report regarding the spot of accident, the vehicle which cause the accident and regarding the physical disability of deceased. (v) He has further submitted that owing to the physical disability, it was impossible for the deceased to have reached the alleged spot of accident. (vi) The person who made a PCR call has not been cited as a witness. (vii) It has further pointed out that they are material contradiction between the site plan and the photograph of the spot of the accident placed on record by the prosecution. It is attempted to be contended that contrary to the claim of the prosecution regarding the existence of a service lane, as reflected in the site plan, the service lane is conspicuously missing in the photographs. (viii) It is further pointed out that the site plan also illustrates that the TSR was standing in the middle of the road but the chargesheet is silent about the said TSR or its driver. (ix) It is further pointed out that the mechanical inspection report answers a question in negative regarding the condition of the braking system whereas when the vehicle was released on superdari it was found that braking system of the vehicle was in perfect working condition. CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.4/6 -- 4 of 6 -- 6. In the case at hand, one eye witness Mohd. Sikander has leveled specific allegations against the revisionist wherein he has vividly explained the incident and has alleged that the revisionist caused the accident by driving his vehicle in rash and negligent manner. It is a settled proposition of law that at this stage the Court is not required to test the veracity of the prosecution witnesses. The Court is merely required to sift the evidence available on record to formulate a prima facie opinion. Reliance is placed upon judgment of Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Sheoraj Singh Ahlawat v. State of U.P, reported in (2013) 11 SCC 476, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed that at the stage of framing of charge the court is required to evaluate the material and documents on record with a view to find out if the facts emerging therefrom, taken at their face value, discloses the existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged offence. The court is not expected to go deep into the probative value of the material on record and what needs to be considered is whether there is a ground for presuming that the offence has been committed and not a ground for convicting the accused has been made out. At this stage, even strong suspicion founded on material which leads the court to form a presumptive opinion as to the existence of the factual ingredients constituting the offence alleged would justify the framing of charge against the accused in respect of the commission of that offence. 7. In my considered opinion disputed questions of fact of law are beyond the revisional jurisdiction of this Court and can only be adjudicated upon by the Ld. Trial Court at an appropriate CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.5/6 -- 5 of 6 -- stage. Considering the totality of circumstances, I do not find any illegality or material irregularity in the impugned order dated 15.10.2022. The revision petition is found to be bereft of any merits and the same is accordingly dismissed. 8. Trial Court's Record be sent back alongwith copy of the present order for necessary information. 9. Copy of present order be given dasti as requested. 10. Revision file be consigned to record room after necessary compliance. Announced in open court today on 21.04.2023 (Dharmender Rana) ASJ/Special Judge, NDPS (Central) Tis Hazari Courts Delhi/21.04.2023 CR No. 57/2023 Anmol Khurana Vs. The State Page No.6/6 -- 6 of 6 --
